illustration by Sorit
opinion
Bindra's Bogus Patriotism
And how money-grubbing Board mandarins are ruining cricket
It's a matter of great shame that some members of the Indian Cricket Board (BCCI) still remain feudal lords of the past. This realisation hit me during the recording of NDTV's We The People programme, hosted by Barkha Dutt, last week. Barkha is an immaculate presenter of a very popular programme of human interest issues ranging from natural disasters and communal riots to calamities in such places as Afghanistan and Pakistan. She's a person of substantial intellect and compassion.

I'm a great fan of Barkha because she takes on the high and the mighty and loves to call a spade a shovel if need be. She's knowledgable and articulate, but some of her guests are downright ignorant and arrogant. The programme I was part of examined Cricket vs Terror in the aftermath of the attack on the Sri Lankan team in Lahore.

The natural point of debate during the discussion was how safe India was to host the IPL, with its dates clashing with that of the general election, and with both the home ministry and the IPL machinery at a loss to provide foolproof security for both events simultaneously. In the wake of the 26/11 attack, and with the background of blasts in Jaipur during the inaugural IPL jamboree, this gains critical importance.

Terror clouds are hovering over the subcontinent. Some foreign players have already expressed apprehensions about taking part in the second episode of the IPL. But if some are least bothered about the dangers lying ahead, they are the BCCI and its ancillary, the IPL governing council. They're blissfully unaware of terrorists who might lurk in general elections booths as well as in IPL venues.

The BCCI is adamant that both the elections and the IPL can run smoothly with proper distribution of security forces—some wishful thinking that. Most of the crowd in Barkha's programme was either ignorant about the quality of the cricket dished out by the IPL or was just arrogant about the moolah to be reaped. "You don't know anything about it, it's a different game today," snigger the BCCI mandarins smugly.

My own view is that with the IPL, cricket has reached its nadir. Add to that the constant fear of terrorist attacks. Home-grown terrorist groups, both Hindutva and Islamic elements, have shown they will stop at nothing to gain their warped, ghastly ends. Still, the mandarins say that "life must go on as it ought to", no matter how many fall prey to the bullets of the terrorists.

The BCCI, or more precisely the wheelers and dealers of the IPL, couldn't be bothered. Postponing the IPL for a few days is unacceptable to them, and the Lok Sabha polls are of little consequence. What counts is the money spinning into the BCCI's coffers, no matter how. If, in the process, a few human lives are lost, so be it. One gentleman, R.K. Pachauri, sensibly suggested that no action be taken in haste. But his voice was often lost, as normally happens in a crowd of irrelevance. Poor Barkha was at a loss to gauge every opinion in the hall. In any case, the few cricket purists present were outnumbered by those who couldn't care less if the game's basic character was destroyed and rubbed into the dust.

At one point, I.S. Bindra, the president of the Punjab Cricket Association, kept on harping about the IPL and national pride—knowing fully well that club cricket can't be associated with national pride. I couldn't take this bogus appeal to national pride and had to remind him of our meeting in 1984 during the anti-Sikh riots in Delhi, when I was without a shelter for a long time. Most reluctantly, I'd gone to see him in the Rashtrapati Bhavan, where he was then the special assistant to the President of India, to seek help.

Like a fool, I expressed my frustration that I could either return to my hometown in Amritsar, where I had little or nothing to do, or leave this country. Prompt came the helping hand: "If I were you Bishen, I'd leave this country!" What a magnificent piece of advice coming from the country's highest office! And the same man is now lecturing us about national pride.

At the NDTV studio, as I narrated this incident, I thought I heard him say "bullshit", at which I had to ask him to mind his language in public. With administrators like him in cricket, national pride is an obsolete idea. Once, he even questioned my wife: "What have you given Bishen except two children?" That explains exactly the sort of man he is.




(Bishen Singh Bedi is a former captain of India)
 
Daily MailPublished
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Apr 13, 2009 12:00 AM
8
Bishen Singh Bedi was a great bowler and from time to time he has offended numerous top-ranking people. Nevertheless, one should not rule out everyting he says. Security is a very important matter and the BCCI has shown time and again that is more interested in Almighty dollar than in the players - who as Gilchrist said could be bought like cattle. He is also correct in stating that national pride does not depend on the IPL, but in Team India winning. The IPL is purely a business venture.
R Sivasubramaniam
Singapore, Singapore
Mar 22, 2009 12:00 AM
7
one who is most hypcrate is mr bedi himself,who called ganguly india's worst captain,why coz he doesn't played his chela sunil joshi. called ones sunil gavaskar a bad efffect on indian cricket. he likes to see the cricket played in 60 area when most of the test were drawn,if he was playing now days sehwag will sure come in to your dream,ones in crickinfo magzine i read an article about cricket show in news channel titled zoo cricket and one of the show in zee news mr bedi was the main culprit written in that article. mr bedi is some one like karan thapar who think being nasty is their usp and it reflect their truesworthy but mr bedi one is for sure thank god you are not part of indian cricket now days
anurag narayan
delhi, India
Mar 18, 2009 12:00 AM
6
haha, DIP, good analysis...
Raj
Leipzig, Germany
Mar 17, 2009 12:00 AM
5
Now take the gist:

First part: Flattery to satisfy the all important Barkha Dutt
Middle Portion: A sloppy justification of his core opinion
Conclusion: Personal vengeance – could not just hide the very purpose of his writing
dip
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Mar 17, 2009 12:00 AM
4
Strange though it may sound, Bedi in his own narration mentions that it was he who broached the idea of 'leaving the country' in his discussion with Bedi. That is such a huge paradox. Bedi has a knack for putting his foot in the mouth.
Mohan Awara
New Delhi, India
Mar 15, 2009 12:00 AM
3
Bishen Bedi has contributed more to India's 'national pride' than many of the pompous jokers sitting in the BCCI, who are little more than pocket lining banias. Besides, anyone with a half-brain will agree that this is not the time to stage a high-profile event like the IPL. Terror clouds may not be hovering over the subcontinent, but the Mumbai attacks have demonstrated how much of a joke our security agencies are. One can only imagine how secure we will be even this security apparatus (or the lack of it) is kept busy during elections. Th IPL will have to go on without any secrity whatsoever, offering an excellent opportunity for more armed street-urchins from a certain neighbouring country to come here and create havoc. God forbid, if something happens, India will join the ranks of pariah countries like our next door neighbour, where nobody will want to play cricket again. Will the BCCI never learn, other than the hard way?
G.Natrajan
Hyderabad, India
Mar 15, 2009 12:00 AM
2
Bishen Bedi is happy to get a forum to rant, rave or just plain show up and be seen. The few people that still want to listen to him include Vinod Mehta and Barkha Dutt.
In Mr. Bedi’s view, “with IPL, cricket has reached its nadir”. Mr. Bedi barely tolerated one day cricket played over 50 overs for so long but now obviously he has had enough. Publicly expressed sentiments of several top-flight cricketers who proclaim the improvements in their techniques and aggressiveness to the pressures of playing T20 cricket obviously do not matter to him. Why must only cricket played over 5 days be called cricket? What about cricket played over 3 days or 4? Perhaps Mr. Bedi pictures himself facing Kevin Pietersen or Sehwag in a rival team in the T20 format and does not like what he sees.
At least on the matter of cricket, Mr Bedi has some knowledge even if he allows his judgment to get clouded many times. Calling Murali a chucker or worse is just one example of gratuituous insult peddling that is so typical of Bedi. Mr Bedi has zero knowledge of security matters. He is sitting in relative anonymity of Delhi, under no threat whatsoever compared with what some of the current players are exposed to. Yet, voices of the current players have been vocal in support of IPL while Mr. Bedi rants about constant fear of terror attacks from Hindutva groups and Islamic terrorists.
I am not taking a stand either for or against IPL. It is a fairly complex endevour even in normal times. Experts will need to be involved and they need to bring their issues and fears on the table and pull together resources to solve them. If in the opinion of those experts, IPL needs to be rescheduled or cancelled, so be it. Taking recourse to lurid prose like “terror clouds are hovering over the subcontinent” can’t substitute for logic or reason. Taking advantage of Vinod Mehta’s desire to stir up controversy to help sell copies of his magazine to run down someone who he claims was once a friend reflects more on Bedi than Bindra.
After a lifetime of playing cricket and coaching (not very successfully unless you count tips handed out to visiting spinners), Bishen Bedi has very few friends in the game.
Anindya Chatterjee
New Delhi, India
Mar 14, 2009 12:00 AM
1
Hi Bishen,
If you went to Bindra during your worst hour of crisis, I assume that he must have been your friend. Whatever he said about "leaving the country" might have been said out of sheer frustration and agony.

Many of my close Sikh friends wanted to leave the country in 1984. (Thank God the didn't leave, though) It's quite possible that Bindra didn't mean what he said. But you are a real bad guy. You kept it in your memory bank and brought it out after nearly 24 years.

You resorted to discussing personal affairs during a public debate.

If Bindra is mean, you are no less. He said, "bullshit", but it was you who made the shit hit the ceiling.

I have known you as a very good bowler but a bad Captain; a flop coach; Now I add another adjective to your name- a dangerous friend.
Sudhir Kumar Bisht
Delhi, India
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY