For The Record
The Police 'Must Introspect Deeply'
'To-day, aspersions are being made regarding police impartiality and capabilities, and while I recognize that much of this is motivated, you must face up to the reality that many are convinced that the police is less than fair. This is so even when policemen die in the line of duty'
PM's address at the DGP's Conference, 2008, New Delhi

At the outset, I would like to congratulate the recipients of the highly coveted President's Police Medal for Distinguished Service. Their consistent and excellent performance in a difficult sector of policing has earned them this medal. I am sure that they would continue to strive harder to achieve still greater heights in their profession.

In October last year, I had an opportunity to address the Conference of Directors-General of Police. The international environment is in far greater turmoil to-day than it was a year ago. This has major consequences for us, for in a globalised world, what affects one part of the globe often affects the other parts as well. The current international financial crisis is a good index of the inter-active nature of to-day's globalised world. Likewise, in the realm of security, globalisation has produced a whole new range of interactive threats and risks. Globalisation has also led to a blurring of the distinction between external and internal threats.

It is appropriate that the theme of this year's Conference of Directors-General of Police should be Terrorism. The advent of many non-state actors has greatly increased our vulnerabilities. Terrorism is now recognized as the main scourge of the modern world. To-day's terrorists – whether they be non-state actors or others – use modern communications and exploit cyber space to carry out their disruptive activities, and I hope that this Conference will find ways and means not only to deal with the terrorist problem but also improve the techniques needed for this purpose.

I only wish to emphasise here that time is not on our side. We cannot afford a repetition of the kind of terrorist attacks that have recently taken place in Delhi, Hyderabad, Bangalore, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Surat, Guwahati and some other urban centers. Every time a terrorist attack takes place there is a public outcry over the failure of the Government, accompanied by criticism of the police and the intelligence agencies. I am aware that many terrorist attacks have been prevented, thanks to the vigil of the police and intelligence agencies, but a single incident of reasonable magnitude causes repercussions, and calls into question the capability and capacity of the Government and its agencies. The globalisation of terror has made Terrorism an all-encompassing danger. We should anticipate that the scale of such terrorist incidents would only grow in the future and this would then become a major test of your capacities. You must be prepared for such an eventuality.

Alongside this, we need to guard against the new danger posed by the spread of fundamentalist and extremist ideas. We have, of late, been witnessing the emergence of such pernicious tendencies and trends, and there are elements in our society who are actively pursuing such programmes. We are a nation of over a billion people, belonging to different religions, communities, castes and speaking different languages who have lived peacefully together for hundreds of years. Our inclusive society must be preserved for posterity.

The virus of communal violence that threatens the secular fabric of our country needs to be checked in time, otherwise our multi-religious, multi-ethnic and multi-caste society could well unravel. This cannot be done by the police and law & order agencies alone, but the Police are often the first responders and have, hence, a critical role to play. Many years ago, our first Prime Minister, Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru had remarked: "All of us, of whatever religion we belong to, are equal children of India with equal rights, privileges and obligations…..No nation can be great whose people are narrow in thought or in action." Sixty years and more after Independence, this remains the leit motif of our liberal pluralistic democracy. Whatever be the circumstances, the police must not remain passive spectators, when deliberate efforts are made by communal elements or others to disturb the peace.

It is important that you have a proper understanding of the complex forces that are at work to-day in the country. You will need to avoid stereotypes that might wittingly, or unwittingly, enlarge the fault lines in our society. As the most visible symbol of our pluralistic democracy and national identity, you must create an image of the police as a fair and impartial entity. You will come under attack from those sections of society who are determined to undermine India's liberal ethos, but this challenge will have to be met. You may rest assured that in carrying out your responsibilities and duties you will have the fullest support of our Government.

Another major challenge before the Police will be restoring the faith of the people - specially those belonging to religious and ethnic minorities and the weaker sections - in the impartiality and effectiveness of the police. To-day, aspersions are being made regarding police impartiality and capabilities, and while I recognize that much of this is motivated, you must face up to the reality that many are convinced that the police is less than fair. This is so even when policemen die in the line of duty.

You must introspect deeply why this is happening. An adverse image of the police undermines its efficiency. It makes your task much more difficult. Your work is with, and amongst, people, and you require their support and help. You need to win the trust of civil society. You need understanding from and rapport with the media. Above all you must carry conviction to one and all about your impartiality and honesty of purpose. This is fundamental if the police has to succeed in a democracy. An appropriate media policy, which could assist the police in gaining public confidence, through informing the public about what it needs to know and avoiding random or baseless speculation, is thus important.

In his address yesterday, the Home Minister would have covered the broad trends in the prevailing security scenario. I do not, hence, propose to enlarge upon this. All I would like to add is that while no one is questioning the professional competence of individual members of the Police Force, some misgivings do exist as to whether the police is adequately geared to deal with to-day's complex security problems. The contours of internal security have changed fundamentally over the years, and the basic character of threats has become greatly enlarged and also more complicated. A question that is often posed is whether the police have adequately upgraded their skills, have an indepth understanding of to-day's security problems, are technologically qualified, and have honed their abilities in every direction. In my interaction later to-day, I hope to hear from you what progress has been achieved in these areas.

This is particularly true of the threat posed by Left Wing Extremism – perhaps the most serious internal security threat that we face. It is evident that despite the efforts that have, and are being made, the measures taken so far have not yielded desired results. The police need to demonstrate greater resourcefulness and strengthen in term of both their intelligence machinery and their response capacity. This is equally true in some measure in regard to the threat from terrorist outfits. The inability of the Intelligence - Agencies and the police to obtain pinpointed and actionable intelligence and in time - has enabled these outfits to carry out some high-profile attacks.

There could be several reasons for this, and I am aware of some of them. The resources at the disposal of the police are often inadequate. The strength of personnel in police stations clearly needs to be augmented. There are far too many vacancies, and much larger numbers need to be recruited into the police, particularly into the civil police. The intelligence machinery at both the State and Central levels needs to be upgraded and should be more sophisticated. Police training has not kept pace with requirements. A quantum increase in the Police Budget across the country is also called for.

There is a great deal, notwithstanding all these limitations, that you could still do as leaders of the police force. To begin with, closer supervision at every level of the police hierarchy would yield better results. There is scope for effective connectivity between a policeman on duty and his headquarters through an effective and advanced communication system that could result in a 2-way flow of messages and data. With more senior level appointments in the Police, it should be possible to innovate better and create new instrumentalities for more effective policing. Training, in particular, can receive greater attention. Efforts can also be concentrated as much on the lowly beat constable as on members of Specialized Forces such as the Greyhounds in Andhra Pradesh and the COBRA battalions of the CRPF.

I am aware that some work is already in place and the Ministry of Home Affairs and the various agencies under the MHA, including the Bureau of Police Research & Development, are engaged in this task. Yet, as I just stated, when it comes to high-tech crimes, terrorist situations, insurgent problems, or complex law & order matters, the perception remains that the police have a great deal of leeway to make up. This is something that has to be taken up urgently.

There is thus a great deal of pressure to re-energise and re-vitalise the police force. In 2005, while addressing the Conference of Directors-General of Police, I had recommended a 'Police Mission' approach with a view to achieving focused attention on different police related tasks. The intention was to create an image of the Indian Police as a professionally competent and technologically advanced force, one that would be an agent of socio-economic change endowed with a spirit of humanism. I am told that some steps have been taken in this direction and meetings of the 'Micro Missions' that were established have been held. On the ground, however, tangible results are yet to be seen. I think a Committee of the Directors-General of Police should assess what needs to be done so that the original spirit with which the idea of the 'Police Mission' was initiated, is re-created.

I believe that in the dynamic environment that we find ourselves, in which the pace, scale and complexity of changes are unprecedented, we need and should evolve a networked security architecture. Risks are often unforeseen in to-day's work. Threats are often hidden. This has made the work of law and order professionals far more challenging than previously. We need to be able to anticipate better. To ensure a proper networked security architecture, I suggest the establishment of a Task Force which would initiate a 100-day plan to:

  • Develop an integrated capability to address emerging challenges in areas such as Left Wing Extremism, Terrorism and Insurgency;
  • Improve the ability to anticipate and prevent surprises, through closely networked intelligence collaboration and upgradation of both human and technological intelligence;
  • Create an awareness regarding the critical importance of strategic foresight in regard to social and political developments;
  • Develop a net-centric information command structure that enables State and Central agencies to access and exploit information in a secure manner;
  • Strengthen inter-State and inter-agency collaboration;
  • Ensure innovation and technological leadership.

In a period of 100 days, the Task Force should come out with a road map regarding the detailed steps to be taken immediately, as also the subsequent steps to be taken over the next several months so as to translate this vision of an integrated net-centric capability into reality. The Task Force could be chaired by the National Security Adviser with suitable representation from the Central and State agencies.

I also suggest the setting up of a Standing Committee of State DGPs to advise the Government on police and police-related legal matters. This institutional mechanism could comprise five State DGPs taken on a rotation basis. Side by side with this, it would be advantageous if the MHA could devise a scheme by which a certain number of Executive level police personnel could be inducted into the Ministry to help with policy formulation and induce a degree of field experience into various formulations involving police matters.

I am sure the DIB and the DGPs and other delegates would work towards these objectives.

In conclusion, I would like to congratulate you and through you the members of the Police Force for the selfless and untiring work that you have been performing. The Police are seldom praised and are almost always the butt of criticism. Nevertheless, the work done by the Police is invaluable and our nation has every reason to be thankful to the two million strong Police Force of the country.

 
Daily Mail
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Dec 02, 2008 12:00 AM
24
New Delhi : The Supreme Court Monday transferred the trial of 85 Godhra train carnage accused, absolved of terrorism charges but indicted for normal penal offences by a central review committee under anti-terror law, to a normal sessions court from the special anti-terror court.

A bench headed by Chief Justice K.G. Balakrishnan ordered the special anti-terror court at Sabarmati in Ahmedabad, set up under now-repealed Prevention of Terrorism Act, to send all the records of cases pertaining to the 85 accused persons to the normal sessions court at Godhra.

The bench, which also included Justice R.V. Raveendran and Justice Dalveer Bhandrai, also asked the Godhra sessions court to expeditiously decide on the bail pleas of all the accused persons in view of the fact that they all had been languishing in jail since April 2004.

Facing stringent terror charges under the now-repealed POTA, the bail of all the accused were dismissed by various courts, including the Gujarat high court.

The central review committee, set up under the 2004 law repealing POTA, while examining the veracity of the terror charges against the accused, had recommended dropping of the stringent clauses and that they be tried under provisions of the Indian Penal Code for allegedly setting fire to the S-6 sleeper coach of Sabarmati Express, thereby killing 69 Hindu pilgrims on board.

The apex court ordered transfer of the trial of accused to a normal sessions court on a bunch of petitions by them seeking bail for themselves from the apex court after dropping of the POTA charges against them. (IANS).
Anwar Patel
Dallas Tx, United States
Nov 30, 2008 12:00 AM
23
This is a very prophetic speech.

" only wish to emphasise here that time is not on our side. We cannot afford a repetition of the kind of terrorist attacks that have recently taken place in Delhi, Hyderabad, Bangalore, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Surat, Guwahati ..."

And this

"but a single incident of reasonable magnitude causes repercussions, and calls into question the capability and capacity of the Government and its agencies"

THis takes the cake
"We should anticipate that the scale of such terrorist incidents would only grow in the future and this would then become a major test of your capacities. You must be prepared for such an eventuality."

It is "you " who must be prepared. The PM, Home Minister and others can worry about more important things.


Ganesan
Nj, USA
Nov 30, 2008 12:00 AM
22
What hypocrisy! It's no secret that the cops are corrupt and inept and incompetent, and ill-trained, ill-equipped etc, but they are that only because they have to kow-tow to their power-hungry, corrupt political masters. In the US, a lowly cop can pull over even a Senator or Congressman and give him a ticket or even arrest him if found breaking the law- even the Presidents are kids are not immune. In India if any cop even dare give a ticket to any Parliamentarian, especially one from the ruling party, he instantly finds out what hell looks like.
Yessirree- the present Indian police are no different from his Colonial counterpart- he's the tool of govt- his foremost duty is to protect the govt against the aad aaadmi, which in Congress parlance and true Commies, the party is the govt and govt is the party- and the cops are the play-thing of corrupt netas. That's how come a PM can brazenly, openly and publicly buy the votes of MLAs to keep his govt in power, as no police in this fetid land can even dare make out a case against him, far less issue an arrest warrant.
Bodh
Springfield, United States
Nov 30, 2008 12:00 AM
21
Cdr AV:>>" No amount of police reforms or reorganisation will work as long as the police brass feel indebted to the politicos and hence run to do their bidding."

right. democracy will only be a demonarchy, if the police-men operate only as politicians' men.
v.seshadri
chennai, india
Nov 29, 2008 12:00 AM
20
viswanathan

350 secureity men gaurd mayawati-

an army of men gaurd the gandhi house hold.

even the toothless dog, is gaurded day and night.

likewise criminals in the govt get huge secureity.'

the ordinary amm admi gets lectures on patriotism. i will thank any terrorist luck if he can get us rid of such skum bags.

next in line should be the journalists who seem to be working for pakistan. when this is done most papers would have lots of vacancies.
especially outlookindia.
lalitmb
kalundborg, Denmark
Nov 29, 2008 12:00 AM
19
Why blame Dr Manmohan Singh for all the ills of the police. Every single politician - it doesn't matter to which party he belongs - misuses the police to harrass his political opponents the moment he takes office and gets control over the police.

All politicians mouth platitutdes but no one is prepared to leave the police alone to perform its duties without interference. Quoting examples is a waste of time as we would run out of space on this forum.

The bulk of the NSG instead of standing by for emergencies is deployed on VIP security. A politician hasn't arrived unless he is accompanied by Black Cats to the toilet. Why do all these politicians require so much protection from the people they claim to serve?

The intelligence services, when they are not fighting turf wars, are too busy spying on the opponents of the ruling party (it doesn't matter which one) to have any time to monitor the enemies of the state.

Are any of our intelligence chiefs experts in this field. A posting in the intelligence wing or services is a temporary assignment until the individual can move on to better things. As long as the intelligence services are staffed by part timers they will never be effective.

The police have been reduced to political pawns and their credibility is zero. Little wonder that when the Delhi police arrest certain individuals in connection with the Delhi bomb blasts they are castigated by some parties as being biased against a particular community. And when the Maharashtra ATS arrests some individuals in connection with the Malegaon blasts they are accused of acting on behalf of the ruling party to tarnish the opposition before elections.

The Nuremburg trials established that it was not a defence when accused of a war crime to plead that one was following orders when the orders were illegal. The police need to understand that they are duty bound to observe the rule of law and not the whims of their political masters when these are illegal. Until we have honest senior police officers with the gumption to tell their political bosses that they are not their personal hit squads, this situation will not change.

Look at the condition of the average policeman. He is uneducated, physically unfit, ill trained, ill equipped and with rare exceptions totally un motivated. The policy of reservation has a role to play to ensure that all sections of society are adequately represented in the police. But when merit is given the go by in selection and promotion and standards are lowered to ensure quotas are filled, you will get what you have got.

No amount of police reforms or reorganisation will work as long as the police brass feel indebted to the politicos and hence run to do their bidding.

Dr Manmohan Singh would do better to see that his party sets an example rather than preach to others.
Cdr Arun Visvanathan
Chennai, India
Nov 28, 2008 12:00 AM
18
How ironic that this weak PM is educating police on better policing while being completely oblivious to the dangers faced by the nation.

This from a beauracrat (he does not have any qualities of a leader) who took credit for all the reforms initiated by late PM Narasimha Rao.

He does not represent common indian men. Failure of this goverment in handling security situation after series of attacks all over india, not leveraging pakistan's weak economic and political situation and changing relations and dynamics of indo-US relations this government is a complete failure. Congress will have to find a partner better than corrupt scoundrels of CPM CPI and the likes.

India needs to get up and run. Who are we kidding when blames and accusations of divisive politics is hurled at BJP when this populist government has done nothing but created divisions based on race cast religion economic status as well as political ideology and given higher inflation failing markets and teetering infrastructure.
Alap
Alexandria, USA
Nov 27, 2008 12:00 AM
17
THE PM MUST INTROSPECT AFTER WHAT IS HAPPENING IN MUMBAI NOW. SUCH A WELL COORDINATED ATTACK CAN NOT TAKE PLACE WITHOUT SUBSTANTIAL PREPARATION AND THE UPA GOVT HAS FAILED TO PROVIDE THE TOOLS OF PREVENTING SUCH ATTACKS TO THE INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES AND THE SECURITY FORCES.
A Nair
Bangalore, India
Nov 27, 2008 12:00 AM
16
Once upon a time, I was dead against USA, UK and ISRAEL. Now I support them. All peace loving people should support them. They are doing what is good for humanity. India is incapable of doing the same for vote bank concerns of its political parties. But US,UK,ISRAEL,RUSSIA can and they are eliminating the green viruses which good for the whole of mankind. Six million Israelis has gifted many great things to the world, while the Arab pigs are only bringing sufferings to the humanity. In fact the green viruses of Arabian deserts are as useful as the AIDS virus is to the world.

The green viruses are pushing the World too far. But they should be careful, the day the kind and strong of the world lose their patience, the place will be vaporized the very place the green satans are drawing their satanic inspiration for centuries now.
jaleel
luknow, India
Nov 27, 2008 12:00 AM
15
The bastards, m***********s of Congress, Samajwadi,Lallo are helping the terrorists because of their vote bank calculations. Patriotic Indians, please!!!!! never vote for Congress. Bring back BJP, Siv Sena to power and we Indians will be safe.

The Italian b**ch, or Manmohan Singh, Sivaraj Patil the cowards are useless bastards. We needn't heed their blaberings.

But I wonder, while the bastard ManMohan lost his sleeps over the fate of Glasgow bomber, does he lose his sleeps when innocent Indians are killed by the pigheaded Jihadis ?

Manmohan, you are a disgrace to the gallant, heroic Sikh community.
jaleel
luknow, India
Nov 27, 2008 12:00 AM
14
The police are torturers of people.
The police are murderers of innocent people in false encounters.
The police are rapists in uniform.
The police are the root cause for violence and crimes to abound.
These are well known facts and can be substantiated from news from around the world.
For example read the current news (BBC,etc.)of Yang Jia who was tortured in police custody in China so much (sodomising and all)that he took the extreme step of murdering 6 policemen after he was released.
Mort
Bombay, India
Nov 27, 2008 12:00 AM
13
Terror strikes in Bombay.

WHile Swami Manmohananda is busy lecturing others to introspect. And being in nihsta while not lecturing others.

Swamiji wont lift a finger to fight terror.
Ganesan
Nj, USA
Nov 26, 2008 12:00 AM
12
As long asbonafide crminals like Abu Salem are not tried under MCOCA and suspected ones liek Sadhvi are tried under one.. congressi have no face to tell anyone anything..

make up youor mind will it be special law or not this selctive use of special law agaisnt hindu suspects will not work..
Rahul
Delhi, India
Nov 26, 2008 12:00 AM
11
Have you guys noticed that now his tenure is about to end he is comign up with these vacuuous words for police surprise surpirse he is even now considering some new law agianst terror..

Meanwhile the line of congress that special law is not needed is exposed now that they have tried sadhvi and others under MCOCA..

btw MAharashtra govt dropped MCOCa charge against Abu Salme.. tells you all you need to know about this govt..
Rahul
Delhi, India
Nov 26, 2008 12:00 AM
10
For police to actually do anythign meanignful they will have to takne away from duties like assembling MPS through hook or crook for saving crook like Manmhan singh in confidence vote.....

CBI IB all were busy dealing with MPS in last confidence vote.
Rahul
Delhi, India
Nov 26, 2008 12:00 AM
9
>> "The virus of communal violence that threatens the secular fabric of our country needs to be checked in time, otherwise our multi-religious, multi-ethnic and multi-caste society could well unravel. This cannot be done by the police and law & order agencies alone, but the Police are often the first responders and have, hence, a critical role to play. Many years ago, our first Prime Minister, Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru had remarked: "All of us, of whatever religion we belong to, are equal children of India with equal rights, privileges and obligations…..No nation can be great whose people are narrow in thought or in action." Sixty years and more after Independence, this remains the leit motif of our liberal pluralistic democracy."

The Prime Minister did exactly the right thing by reminding the police of this cardinal fact at this time.
Anwar Patel
Dallas Tx, United States
Nov 26, 2008 12:00 AM
8
the president, pm, and most ministers have not been selected by the people, but by sonia gandhi,
a person with a school education.

all the ministers includeing the pm have been chosen based on the criteria, that they are weak,
spineless and lack courage and self respect.

their performance confirms this view of mine.
lalitmb
kalundborg, Denmark
Nov 26, 2008 12:00 AM
7

Dear Dr. Manmohan Singh,

Why we always blame the situation when we are the cause?

Having travelled all over the world, I'd say Indian cops are sadly outdated in all aspects as per the world standards.

The Police system in India must be upgraded as per the world standards.

Divide and decentralize the Police System:

1. General Cops
2. Traffic Cops
3. Fire Cops
4. Forrest Cops
5. Marine Cops
6. Railways Cops
7. Highway Cops
8. Airport Cops
9. VIP Cops
10. Parliament Cops
11. Border Cops
12. Cargo & Logistics Cops
13. Industrial Cops
14. Medical Cops
15. Women Cops
16. Rural Cops
17. Political Cops
18. Sports Cops
19. Religious

Instead, we've the age-old khakhied, paunched cops with lathis during all crisis including bomb blasts. It looks funny to see them in those bombing footage blinking what to do next. Is it the way to Super Stardom?

The cops must get:

1. Fair selection process

2. Proper, relevant training programmes

3. Soft skills

4. Technical skills

5. Interstate operation

6. Revised Salary, Perks, and Allowances

7. Washed, Right-sized, Sensible, Modern costumes.

8. Equipements: Bikes, Cars, Vans, Jeeps, Guns, Pistols, Lathis, Wireless Radio, GPS, Knife, Shackles, Boots, etc.

We have the funds and people but political will to change the system and governance.

Wouldn't be logical if we hand over the governance for a System Study to some consulting firms as Indian Railways did so with IIM????

When countries like Germany, Italy, France, other Eurpoean countries as small as Indian states are way ahead of India in all aspects, what does it cost India to be closer to the same developement if not at par with them.

How long are we gonna keep sending people outside and enlarge the exchequer?

When are gonna create our own produtcs and markets that the world can envy about it?

Will you make a new India which can accomodate all those who left her due to crisis?

Are we still under the British infection?

Balme for all the problems in India lies in the eyes and minds of those who blame the problems...
Sasi KC
Reston, United States
Nov 26, 2008 12:00 AM
6
The police have no time for introspection.
They busy intosuction.
Mort
Bombay, India
Nov 25, 2008 12:00 AM
5
A man who was the Governor of RBI must have detected long long back that his Home Minister Patil is a fake one.Stll he did not or was not allowed to remove him.

Hence PM is morally and administratively fully responsible for the Law and Order situation we are in ;whatever may be Manmohan's constraints .
a k ghai
mumbai, India
Nov 25, 2008 12:00 AM
4
Man Mohan Singh is the Prime Minister of the country. We have made him head of the nation to root out problem. We are not here to read his lectures. If he can not rule the country better should step down. We have never seen such a week and spineless leader.
Mrs Bhanumati
Jhansi, UP, India, India
Nov 25, 2008 12:00 AM
3
Indian police is known for its barbarism and partisan attitude. The virus of regionalism, caste and language have infected our police systems.
Mrs Bhanumati
Jhansi, UP, India, India
Nov 25, 2008 12:00 AM
2


Devandra is right! Almost on a daily basis today, blasts keep going off, and the police are lacking investigating skills required to get to the bottom of it. Even the cases 'cracked' by it, are only due to information given to it by dissident groups.

And yet the Home Minister cannot be replaced, probably because they lack someone with better skills.

The Indian police is busy making money by involving itself in domestic kitchen politics, given the draconian laws passed by the cursed feminist government.

Parthasarathy
Chennai, India
Nov 25, 2008 12:00 AM
1
This is shocking, PM is talkig as if he is just as an auditor or consultant. As a head of a state, he is also responsible for the sorry state of the agency which is guardian of law & order of the state.
Devendra Patel
Ahmedabad, India
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY