Way out: There are NV protests every Friday; one in Bethlehem on Christmas day
palestine: gandhi's way
Gandhis Of Olive Country
Another path to peace? Palestinians revel in Gandhi and the nonviolent struggle.
palestine: gandhi
In between all the violence, Mubarak Awad has slowly brought the Gandhian way to bear
Robert Hirschfield
I'm sitting with Robert Hirschfield at the corner ice-cream shop, tall windows facing the street, steaming mint tea in our glass mugs. Outside, a large group of angry young PLO supporters are waving their fists and their kaffiyas, shouting slogans against the Hamas' massacre of 14 Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) members in Gaza. We are in Ramallah, the interim capital of Palestine, two American Jewish writers, and I am thinking we are crazy.
 
 
Abdullah Rahma of the Bil'in resistance says, "What Gandhi did for his people, I want to do for mine."
 
 
Hirschfield, 68, is comfortable. He has been travelling through Palestine for a month now, researching his book on Palestinian non-violence. He likes it here. "There is an aliveness, an open and present friendliness, a warmth," he says. Outside, the shouting gets louder. I, sorry to say, think of Daniel Pearl; Hirschfield of Mahatma Gandhi.

It was the visit of Arun Gandhi—the Mahatma's grandson—to Palestine in 2004 that first caught Hirschfield's interest. "In the United States," Hirschfield says, "Palestinians are seldom portrayed as anything other than terrorists. Sure the terror is real, and Israel must defend herself. But why stigmatise the whole of the Palestinian people?" It was this point Arun Gandhi addressed on his Palestine visit. "Imagine yourselves marching by the thousands behind your leaders, demanding the right to be treated as human beings," he had asked a large audience of Palestinians and their Israeli sympathisers. "Sit at the roadblocks and sing your songs. March to the wall and dance your dances."

No mass march followed this perhaps naive plea, but Arun's message was absorbed, part of a continuing Palestinian debate on the viability of a nonviolent (NV) resolution to the Israeli occupation. "We are looking forward to a Palestinian satyagraha," answered Hanna Amireh, of the PLO executive committee, to Arun. "In spite of the fact that Palestine might not be ready for that yet, we believe the way of Mahatma Gandhi should find an abiding place in the Palestinian struggle for freedom."

The most well-publicised NV "revolt" is happening at the village of Bil'in.
 
 
'Combatants for peace' unites former Israeli and Palestinian fighters in NV actions against the occupation.
 
 
When Israel confiscated, in 2004, several thousands of acres of this village to build the security wall between the two countries from north to south, hundreds of Palestinians and Israelis started coming to weekly Friday NV resistance actions here. It included chaining themselves to olive trees and holding weddings on the confiscated land. Some 800 have been injured, many have been arrested. The Israeli supreme court recently ruled in their favour, but only partially. The protests continue. Abdullah Abu Rahma, the director of the coalition at Bil'in, told Hirschfield, "What Gandhi did for his people, I want to do for mine."


Gandhi messages on the HLT board

"The history of Palestinian NV is long and courageous, but not well-known," says Hirschfield, a writer's writer whose discovery of the Palestinian NV movement has developed into an intensely personal passion, leading him all the way from New York's Lower East Side to the towns and alleyways of Palestine. "It is not quite a story of ahimsa, not in the spiritual sense. Usually, NV activism has been used here as a way to an end. But," he adds, "certainly, there are many who choose NV because it is just that—nonviolent."

We are joined at the Ramallah ice-cream shop by Hizami Jabri, a 36-year-old father of five young girls, who has served two terms in Israeli jails and was shot in his shoulder during a violent agitation. "I started to ask myself, how could I have a good life? How could my people have a good life? This violence, it cannot bring a good life," says Jabri, a member of the Palestine Authority's preventative security force by day, an NV trainer for the NGO MEND (Middle East Nonviolence and Democracy) after hours. He tells us, as many do, that the success of NV in India gives him strength, inspiration. There is shy pride in his hazel eyes when he says, "My daughters have taught NV conflict resolution to all the other kids in the neighbourhood. They are a new generation."


Spread the word: Nonviolence and conflict resolution training for 'trainers' in Hebron

Hirschfield tells us of another NGO called Combatants for Peace, which unites Israeli and Palestinian ex-fighters in NV actions against the Israeli occupation. One Palestinian leader of this group, Bassam Aramin, an ex-Fatah fighter who served years in Israeli jails, lost his 10-year-old daughter to a stray Israeli bullet last spring but has not changed his mind about his path; Aramin's Israeli counterpart, Arik, lost his sister in a Palestinian suicide attack. Hirschfield has written about these men in one of his powerful essays: "They are fighters wanting to reframe the fight, wanting a future for their children emptied of the wall posters of martyrs."

My crash course on the history of the Palestine NV movement is set to stunning scenery, seen through the windows of the small local buses. Beige and olive hillsides meet the cream blue sky in a clearly marked line; an ageing man with a child on his back walks slowly through a fallow field. Hirschfield, his white hair worn in an Einstein-like halo, tells me that most Palestinian NV resistance (dating back as far as 1936) has emerged from the grassroots, not taught by a leader or a specific ideology. But the NV technique received a boost during the 1988 uprising (the Intifada), when the underground leadership called the people to use organised, classic NV tactics—boycotts of Israeli goods, tax strikes, planting vegetable gardens, even knitting and sewing their own clothes. The people responded, a peace process did result, but not any real liberation. Now, after one more (extremely violent) 'intifada', inter-Palestinian violence is at an all-time high.

We have reached Bethlehem, the birthplace of Jesus Christ, through a massive and intimidating checkpost. We are visiting the Holy Land Trust (HLT), one of the several Palestinian NGOs dedicated to strengthening and promoting NV on the 'West Bank'. In the hallway, a billboard carries a photo of Mahatma Gandhi with the quote: "Non-violence is not a garment to be put on and off at will.

 
 
"I am reminded of gandhi's words," says Awad, "first they ignore you, then ridicule and fight you, then you win."
 
 
Its seat is in the heart, and it must be an inseparable part of our being." On the hallway bookshelf, a well-worn set of Gandhi's writings, brought back by Mubarak Awad—called Abu Gandhi (see box)—from his India yatra some 25 years ago. "I do not believe Gandhi would agree to definitions such as 'Gandhian'," says Sami Awad, Mubarak's nephew and the executive director of the HLT. "This term holds a sense of division, separateness. But the HLT is founded on the philosophy and the work of Gandhi—in the political, social and spiritual sense." The windows look out over a valley where a large, clustered Israeli settlement blocks the view of the olive groves on the ancient white rock slopes.

Olive trees in Palestine have special significance—they give their first fruit after 70 years. When one plants and tends to a new olive tree, it is an act of unselfish love towards future generations. Palestine is covered in olive groves, but thousands have been cut to build the Wall. Replanting new olive trees has become a major form of civil disobedience, along with rebuilding demolished houses, demonstrating at the Wall, and boycotting Israeli goods. "I am often reminded of the famous quote by Gandhi," says Awad, "'First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win.' The great thing about this quote is the fact that Gandhi did not say—then they fight you, then THEY LOSE. Gandhi said, then YOU WIN. In NV, there are no losers, only winners."


Group therapy: The Gandhi bookshelf; HLT staff and volunteers at the centre

These days, there are never enough seats in the NV trainings given by HLT, MEND, Wi'am and others to supply the rapidly growing demand from women, villagers, PLO fighters, even once a clandestine unit of Hamas. Over the course of three days, 50 or more participants learn to recognise and express their anger; nonviolent conflict resolution; and strategies for civil disobedience. "It's amazing," says Eilda Zaghmout Bandak, the 26-year-old charismatic executive officer of HLT, "participants immediately begin to apply these techniques in their daily lives. We have always felt so helpless, at the mercy of others. Now we feel empowered."

This good news remains under-reported, even in Israel, where there is a majority support for an independent Palestinian country. Three years ago, 'wealthy American businesspeople' sponsored The Gandhi Campaign: the Hollywood film, Gandhi, dubbed in Arabic, was shown in towns and villages across Palestine and Gaza, with the hope that it will inspire NV. (Ben Kingsley, the movie's star, was guest of honour at the premiere). The next day, Avishai Margalit, a writer for Israel's Left-leaning newspaper Haaretz, asked Palestinian friends if there ever could be a Palestinian Gandhi, and why Mubarak Awad had 'failed'. "Nonviolent struggle is perceived in Palestine as unmanly," his friends told him. "There is a strong belief that what was taken by force must be regained by force." The 'left-wing' Israeli blogger Ran HaCohen wrote in response: "The Palestinians don't have to watch the Gandhi film. There are thousands of Palestinian Gandhis out there. Whole villages that demonstrate daily and peacefully against the robbery of their land and livelihood. Still, the only voice we hear is the voice of commentators and movie stars wondering, 'Where is the Palestinian Gandhi?'"

Hirschfield would agree. He is writing his book about these remarkable people, and about his mother as well, a deeply orthodox Jew who lost 25 members of her family in the Holocaust. "My mother was appalled by the violence in the world. She taught me that I must use my life to my power to heal this world. Israel's actions in Palestine fill me with anger, and with immense sadness." He is one of many, on both sides of the grey wall, dedicated to tearing it down by being, as Gandhi famously said, the change they want to see.




(Aimee Ginsburg has been living in India for the past 11 years and is the Indian correspondent for Israel's largest daily, Yediot Achronot. She accompanied Robert Hirschfield to Palestine for researching his book on Palestinian nonviolence.)
palestine: gandhi
In between all the violence, Mubarak Awad has slowly brought the Gandhian way to bear
Robert Hirschfield
 
Daily MailPublished
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Mar 11, 2008 12:00 AM
7
Palestinians first need to demonstrate that they deserve statehood. Desire is next step.
With their violent ways, clearly they don't.

Gandhi's non-violence was lot more than just freedom. Remember he started with Dalit (then called Harijan) upliftment. This is one example to prepare the people to have independence. This is one reason why India did not descend to ungoverned state despite having so much linguistic and religious diversity.

Palestinians are addicted to violence. After Israel pulled out from Gaza they started fighting among themselves - between Hamas and Fatah. With blood in hand, I am not sure if they will stop their violent ways even if they get full statehood and Israel cease to exist.
Rajesh
Phoenix, United States
Mar 10, 2008 12:00 AM
6
This is what is so perniciously wrong with the media.It makes mountains out of molehills just for sensation and making a fast buck.
Rajeswari Nanduri
Atlanta, United States
Mar 10, 2008 12:00 AM
5
Bullcrap. Outlook shouldn't spout such nonsense. We all know how well NV has worked with Dalai Lama in Tibet. You must be "powerful" to survive otherwise you will be squashed by the big bully. On a different note it always surprises me how the Gandhi-Nehru family (and Congress Party which is completely different from INC though many in India don't know it) take total credit always for India's freedom struggle. Their role is highly exaggerated. It is highly demeaning to others like Netaji, Bhagat Singh, Savarkar, Patel, Lal Bal Pal, rajaji, VOC...
ARVIND
ROCHESTER, United States
Mar 10, 2008 12:00 AM
4
It is no wonder that Palenstinians like Gandhi-for preferred the jewish race to go extinct in upholding the principle of non violence rather than to survive. He says in 1938 to a group of missionaries
"Take the question of the Jews on which I have written. No Jew need feel helpless if he takes the non-violent way. A friend has written me a letter objecting that in that article I have assumed that the Jews have been violent. It is true that the Jews have not been actively violent in their own persons. But they called down upon the Germans the curses of mankind, and they wanted America and England to fight Germany on their behalf. If I hit my adversary, that is of course violence, but to be truly non-violent, I must love him and pray for him even when he hits me. The Jews have not been actively non-violent or, in spite of the misdeeds of the dictators, they would say, "We shall suffer at their hands; they knew no better. But we shall suffer not in the manner in which they want us to suffer." If even one Jew acted thus, he would salve his self-respect and leave an example which, if it became infectious, would save the whole of Jewry and leave a rich heritage to mankind besides. "

And later he writes
"Have I not repeatedly said that active non-violence is unadulterated love - fellow-feeling? And if the Jews, instead of being helplessly and of necessity non-violent, adopt active non-violence, i.e., fellow-feeling for the gentile Germans deliberately, they cannot do any harm to the Germans and I am as certain as I am dictating these lines that the stoniest German heart will melt. Great as have been the Jewish contributions to the world`s progress, this supreme act of theirs will be their greatest contribution and war will be a thing of the past"

Ganesan
Nj, USA
Mar 09, 2008 12:00 AM
3
Nasar, you're absolutely right... non-violence is a good thing, and works only in certain cases... though Gandhi had done a great deal in NV struggle, one of the main reasons it worked with British is b'cos there wasn't a realistic chance that they're gona rule the entire subcontinent with their limited generals and army... and the world wars in Europe also played a very significant role in the strategy of British to leave the subcontinent and concentrate more on home and around, and that they have vast vassals in Australia and Canada for natural resources... people should realize that these are the important factors that contributed to our NV struggle... but the case of Israel and Palestine is entirely different... Those zionist bastards are not having a picnic in Palestine... their sole purpose is to strech the limits of Palestinian people by occupying as much territory as they can, and then 'give away' small hamlets here and there as if they are donating it for free... Israel is buying time... the longer this problem persists the stronger the Israel gets... NV struggle with Israel should be actively supported by the world over, and THE WORLD MUST BOYCOTT ISRAEL IN EVERY ASPECT...
Raj
Dresden, Germany
Mar 09, 2008 12:00 AM
2
Fascinating article. The case has to be made on the conscience of the world. In that respect the movement makes sense, however futile it may sound.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Mar 08, 2008 12:00 AM
1
There is a limit to non violence.Once Gandhi was asked what should a girl do if she was about to be raped.He replied that the girl has the right to vilently to escape and should not submit herself to the attacker.Palestinaian violence is the direct result of the apathy of the world has shown to their plight.They were affable and patient people who underwent a lot of injustice and torture.When the world support the mighty they had no chance but to take the arms.Infact their docility made Moshe Dyan remark you can never humiliate them!Violence begets violence.Times have chnaged since the days of Gandhi.The killing technology and the massmedia manipulations have made the oppressor very strong today and most of the time they are the rich and the exploitative regims of tthe west.The only reason to abjure violence is to stop the cycle of killing and to avoid the heavy loss for the oppressed.There are no easy solutions.Both violence and non violence are justified.But the massmedia can play a crucial role in bringing this cruelity to the masses.Unfortunately either they are not interested or under the diktat of the owners not to publish.As Marshl Mcluhan once said medium is the message.
nasar
Raleigh, USA
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY