Sorit
opinion
The Diaspora Is Inside
Our millions of internal migrants are internal fodder. They must be saved.
maharashtra: politics
Farce or tragedy? Raj is Thackeray Mark-II, down to the tacit Congress profiteering.
Smruti Koppikar
In 1956, Solomon Bandaranaike faced an election in Sri Lanka that he desperately wanted to win. So he jettisoned the country's three-language policy (Sinhala, Tamil and English) and promised to make Sinhala the official language of the country—and duly won a landslide victory. It was an act of pure political opportunism, for Bandaranaike was anything but a Sinhala chauvinist. But it sowed the seeds of a Tamil rebellion that has now lasted for 25 years and all but destroyed the island nation's economic and political future. Today, a similar act of pure, callous political opportunism threatens the future of India.

Raj Thackeray has not suddenly discovered that there are large numbers of north Indians in Mumbai. They were there long before he was born. A study of Mumbai's labour force by Vijay Joshi and Heather Joshi in the early 1960s had shown that workers from Uttar Pradesh formed its second largest component even then. Today, Raj's only purpose in setting his goons upon north Indians in Mumbai is to wrest back control of the Shiv Sena from his cousin Uddhav, to whom it was bequeathed by his father Bal Thackeray in '04. What makes him specially dangerous is that his is more than an act of opportunism, it is also one of filial revenge.

His ploy is already proving abortive, but in the worst possible way. Predictably, Uddhav has responded by starting a north Indian hate campaign of his own. Thus, the goons of the Shiv Sena are now belabouring Biharis and Uttar Pradeshis with as much gusto as those of Raj's Maharashtra Navnirman Sena.

The antics of the two cousins have already been condemned by responsible politicians, and leading members of the intelligentsia in Maharashtra. On February 12, BJP leader L.K. Advani added his voice to the chorus. But so far, most of the critics have focused only on the damage the Thackerays' opportunism could do to Maharashtra. Many have drawn parallels between the cousins' campaign against north Indians and the patriarch's attack on south Indians 40 years ago, and drawn comfort from the fact that the latter had fizzled out and conferred no significant benefit on the Shiv Sena.

But 2008 is not 1968. India has changed dramatically. Thus what had remained a localised assault 40 years ago could easily become the spark that sets the entire country aflame today. The '60s India only had a handful of migrant workers—they had arrived in metros like Bombay and Calcutta in trickles. The Tamils against whom Bal Thackeray launched his campaign had been in Maharashtra for more than two generations. Today, the country has up to a hundred million migrant workers. There are Telugus working in Maharashtra, Oriyas in Gujarat, Rajasthanis all over northern India and Uttar Pradeshis in Punjab and Haryana. There are Biharis in Kashmir and Kashmiris working in Himachal Pradesh.

The most numerous of all are the Biharis. Twenty-five years of caste wars followed by 15 years of Laloo rule has forced an entire generation of Biharis to look for jobs outside their state. Hence, 28 per cent of the adult male population of the state now works in projects and enterprises that stretch from Kashmir to Kanyakumari, from Goa to Arunachal Pradesh.

It is one of the miracles of Indian civilisation that all of them have been accepted peacefully by the host populations. But the opportunity they present to unscrupulous politicians for ephemeral political gain is too great to resist forever. And with the economic gap between the "progressive" and "backward" states growing, this resistance has been eroding. In the past two or three years, small parochial parties have begun to make noises about imposing disabilities upon outsiders with increasing frequency. The Thackerays may give them just the pretext that they have been looking for.

The other great change is in the reach of the media. Forty years ago an anti-Tamil riot in Bombay would be reported only in the print media. The reporting would be circumscribed by government 'D' notices and filtered by vigilant editors for inflammatory content. Most people would therefore only hear about it second or third hand, over a period of days. Today, the news is flashed in gory detail by two dozen TV channels in a dozen languages, within a matter of minutes. People get to see what is happening.

Lopsided development, and the mobilising power of the audio-visual media have therefore turned not just Maharashtra but the whole of India into a tinderbox. Advani deserves credit for having recognised this. But how does one explain the silence from the Congress camp? Aren't Sonia Gandhi and Manmohan Singh staunch defenders of secularism? And isn't racial bigotry a blood brother of religious bigotry? Two decades ago, Indira Gandhi would have boarded Air Force One for Mumbai, considering the gravity of the situation. But the Congress seems to have become a stranger to that kind of leadership today.
maharashtra: politics
Farce or tragedy? Raj is Thackeray Mark-II, down to the tacit Congress profiteering.
Smruti Koppikar
 
Daily Mail
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Mar 05, 2008 12:00 AM
27
Seshadri,

>> Your are saying this to someone who has always been telling you, Allah = Christ = Shiva.

One can say that and yet be a bigot.

>> For you, no moslem ever did or can do anything wrong.

It is you who said that the Gujarat massacres were perpetrated by Pakistanis disguised as adivasis. It is you who advanced the opinion that the kidney harvesting surgeon must be a churchian.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Mar 05, 2008 12:00 AM
26
GF:>>"For you everything is religious. It is your religious bigotry, not theirs."

Your are saying this to someone who has always been telling you, Allah = Christ = Shiva,
eakam sat, vipraa bahudhaa vadanti. For you, no moslem ever did or can do anything wrong. Anyone who points out any moslem/islam-generated problem has to be called a bigot and slandered personally.

As Harish Khare points out in the hindu, some OBC-hindu political-machinists in bihar, UP, like Lallu-Mulayam, as also Gauda in ktka, have encouraged moslem isolationism in these states, as their permanent votebanks, downplayed development and driven most hindu middleclasses out of these states, where kidnapping has become the most profitable occupation, waiting for naxalite takeover. Construction workers are also moving out into other states where some construction is going on. In bihar, there are no bidders for construction-tenders.

Now, Mulayam whose tricks have been exposed in UP, is trying to use moslems in bombay to win some costituencies there, opposed by Raj Tackeray. Lallu, who has made bihar the least-developed state in india, has the least credentials to teach nationalism or development aspirations to the marathis of bombay, by holding some hindu-festival there . But for Shivaji of the marathas, lallu would himself be only some hussain or haniff, today.

v.seshadri
chennai, india
Feb 21, 2008 12:00 AM
25
Seshadri,

>> If one looks carefully, the issue is not racial bigotry, but only religious bigotry, after all. The two opponent leaders arrested and released are only raj thackeray and a moslem leader of salam-vadi party in bombay,

For you everything is religious. It is your religious bigotry, not theirs.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 21, 2008 12:00 AM
24
>>>"And isn't racial bigotry a blood brother of religious bigotry?"

Jha is wrong in calling inter-regional, inter-language and inter-cultural differences among hindus of different parts of India, magnifying them as 'racial difference', as if every district of india is a different 'race'! Suits 'sonia and outlook's churchian policy of divide hindus, appease moslems, empower churchians and rule india dynastically. Jha is just the paid-piper here.

If one looks carefully, the issue is not racial bigotry, but only religious bigotry, after all. The two opponent leaders arrested and released are only raj thackeray and a moslem leader of salam-vadi party in bombay, not mulla singh nor amar singh. Since mayavati has rendered his moslem-votebank political power in UP ineffective by unification of all hindus there, Mulla singh yadav is trying to shift his salam vaadi party base to bombay, utilizing and inciting the moslems of bombay and mahasrashtra as his new votebank under a moslem leader called Azmi. Shiv sainiks of all sections, raj and uddhav, both oppose it, naturally.

The root cause of all these problems is that, while hindus and christians when they move from one part of india to another, the merge, integrate, culturally, even intermarry, except for the churchians playing their conversion tricks, in the case of moslems, they are keen on separate identity, separate civil laws, creation little paks wherever possible, as their population grows. When this happens in a cosmopolitan city like bombay, sensing of danger and reactions are quite justified. When Mayavati held meeting in bombay, there was no reaction. But, when Azmi of salam-vadi party does it, people get concerned.

Jha is trying to sidetrack the issue calling it a 'racial' problem and a 'national' problem to boot. Indians know their races and their nation. Only moslems here are non-indian and no-national in outlook and cause problems and then blame 'hindu bigotry' as the reason for them.
Jha should understand this.
v.seshadri
chennai, india
Feb 21, 2008 12:00 AM
23
I am confused. What is this opinion about? Is it about the reach of the media and a possible political compromise, as usual, by a political party with someone terrorizing a section of Indian society? Where is the law and its enforcement to eliminate this menace of political terrorism once and for all? How must the helpless migrants be saved?
P. Paul
Kartarpur, India
Feb 20, 2008 12:00 AM
22
Mass-migration and thereby demographic change is a real concern. Nowhere in the world this event goes without some heckles being raised by the local population. Anyone who sees India through a prism of a country doesn't know India. It's a continental country and in order to keep it from disintegration economic sops and other incentives must be given to the state whihc are backward . This will be the appropriate political soln of the problem..
Yes cities like Mumbai must be given the status of city-state a truly cosmopolitan centre.

Let not maharshtrians lull theselves into thinking it;s they who have built maharshtra. Maharshtra got all the centres of federeal govt financial institution and thereby a favour done by the centre and every indian form every state has a share in that pie.

Meanwhile Bihar/UP must be brough out of the ecomonc mess they are in..

For raj thackrey u mofof what if tomorrow I go and thrash my colleague from maharahstra working in NOIDA, get a life mororn there is betetr way to drive home the point than the hooliganism.. Congressi stop playing politics take stern action not the tokenism of arrest and release
Rahul
Delhi, India
Feb 20, 2008 12:00 AM
21
Kel Shorey, I would suggets you first try to square the circle of Archbishop of Canterbury asking for Sharia to be Introduced in your country. Or the phenomenon of jihadis and serial bombs in london, targetting you inspite of your "inclusive " culture and absence of "goondas".

The days of "white mans burden " of civilizing the native are long over, if you just woke up.
Shankar
Bangalore, India
Feb 20, 2008 12:00 AM
20
Can some one please answer my simple question? Have Indians in India become some stupid to prop up children like Raj Thackery and his Goondas, and vote them to become leaders? I can not square this circle.
Kel Shorey
Glasgow, United Kingdom
Feb 20, 2008 12:00 AM
19
Varun,

>> this is a common tactic used by the equal-equal crowd, even when not a shred of equivalence can be ascertained.

Congratulations on reaching sainthood, even if it is of the self-anointed variety!
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 19, 2008 12:00 AM
18
Vinod, this is a common tactic used by the equal-equal crowd, even when not a shred of equivalence can be ascertained. See "countercurrents" for some really long-winded stuff about "Hindutva terrorists"- though search in vain for actual terrorist incidents committed by "Hindutva terrorists" that killed enormous amounts of people like the Mumbai train bombing and Hyderabad bombing.
Varun Shekhar
Toronto, CANADA
Feb 19, 2008 12:00 AM
17
Good piece by Mr. Jha. Instead of stressing the common themes that bind our ancient land together, the idiots that go for our "leaders" highlight every little difference, just to create a role for themselves. Witness the rampage by activists of the Kannada Rakshana Vedike in Bangalore in relation to Railway recruitments. Contrast this with the daily sermons by some well meaning saints about Bharat Maata -- our country as our mother.
shapra
Santa Clara, USA
Feb 19, 2008 12:00 AM
16
Chennai: The Tamilnadu Police have arrested an office bearer of Hindu Munnani in connection with the bomb blast at the RSS office in Tenkasi in the Tirunelveli District of Tamilnadu. This latest arrest points to the fact that senior leaders of Sangh Parivar were involved in the conspiracy.

A bomb blast took place at the RSS office at Tenkasi on January 24. After a thorough investigation, the Tamilnadu Police had arrested 7 persons belonging to Sangh Parivar outfits. They had confessed that they indulged in this terror act to instigate the local Hindu population against the Muslims.

On further investigation, the Tamilnadu Police have arrested Siva Alias Sivanandam, who is the General Secretary of Hindu Munnani at Kadayanallur, a neighbouring town of Tenkasi. Formed in 1980, Hindu Munnani is a frontal organisation of Sangh Parivar operating in Tamilnadu.

Siva, who has earlier worked in quarries in the neighbouring state of Kerala had supplied the ammonium nitrate and other raw materials for preparing the bombs. The Tamilnadu Police are further investigating the case. Meanwhile it is reliably learnt that central investigating agencies have collected relevant information from Tamilnadu Police in connection with the blast.

Tenkasi is a busy town in Tirunelveli District of Tamilnadu. Since its location is close to the famous Courtallam waterfalls it attracts a large number of tourists. Hindus belonging to various castes as well as Muslims and Christians have been living in harmony in this town from time immemorial.

Tenkasi means Kasi of South. This town has a famous temple called Kasi Viswanathar Temple. Though the local Sangh Parivar outfit called Hindu Munnani has been long objecting to the renovation of the Bazaar Masjid situated very near to the temple, perfect communal harmony has prevailed in this town.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
15
Arun,

>> We can divide to no end, arrange those divisions in very complex (networked) heirarchies, use those divisions not to understand the other but stereotype and discriminate.

The "other" in South Asia, as also in sub-Saharan Africa, is not just a descriptive allusion that it is in the West. Otherness in India is a highly categorical, fundamental and often condemnatory designation. The result is that entities such as Indianness or humanness have to take a back seat. This seems somehow to militate against the basic tenets of democracy both in theory and in practice.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
14
Ghulam .... "Rule of law and absence of corruption are also important parts of it."

Absolutely. I have many said on this forum that the real hurdle for Indian democracy is "rule of law". It's great we crossed the first hurdle of "free and fair" elections (starting with TN Seshan as EC head) but the "rule of law" hurdle will be much tougher and can take much longer.

In fact I think the first hurdle was easier for us ... as you can think of elections as rituals and be the best in the business of rituals.

Similarly, to cross the hurdle of "rule of law" might be challenge given our history of caste, feudalism, and class - essentially the strong play of hierarchy on the Indian mind. We can divide to no end, arrange those divisions in very complex (networked) heirarchies, use those divisions not to understand the other but stereotype and discriminate. Even more importantly for everyone, in this complex networked hierarchy, there is someone more powerful than us and someone weaker than us - we almost know it intuitively in any setting - almost programmed into us. And then it is natural to be treated badly by those above us and by the same token natural to treat badly someone below us.

Where else would you have a category called the VVIPs as a badge of honor? In fact the way the number of VVIPs is increasingly we will have then have more V's preceding VIP.
Arun Maheshwari
Bangalore, India
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
13
"The BJP has reacted strongly and blamed the state government for delaying action to promote its own interests. The BJP’s anger is understandable as it is an ally of Shiv Sena in Maharashtra and any threat to Shiv Sena is threat to itself. Mr. L.K. Advani, opposition’s candidate for Prime Ministerial post, denounced Raj Thackeray’s regional chauvinism as divisive. What a charge! Mr. Advani plays no less divisive politics. Raj is playing divisive politics between Maharashtrians and North Indians, and Advani is apt at dividing Hindus and Muslims. All three i.e. BJP, Shiv Sena and MNS are playing narrow provincial or religious chauvinism." (Asghar Engineer)
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
12
Arun,

>> Why blame the politician - we have to first blame ourselves for allowing this kind of discourse and agenda?

Identity politics is a major major part of Indian politics. It exists in Western countries too, but to a much smaller extent. In India it can go to the extent of denying the rights of others. When identity based groups deprive others of livelihood, or politicians exploit any and every issue that comes their way, democracy becomes just a word. On a discussion on C-Span today one of the authors of a new book said that having fair elections is not enough to have democracy. Rule of law and absence of corruption are also important parts of it.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
11
Ghulam .... "Our politicians will exploit whatever will bring them votes, irrespective of whether their actions cause national divisiveness or human suffering."

Why blame the politician - we have to first blame ourselves for allowing this kind of discourse and agenda? Why these things by and large don't happen in mature democracies (developed countries) is that this kind of discourse backfires for them in the thing that matter to politicians - getting elected. And their supporters don't take to street as easily because they are penalized by the law-oder machinery.

Bodh ..... "Divide and conquer - the mantra of every two-bit opportunist who've invaded and ruled this poor, balkanized misgotten land."

I have always believed that "dividing" is our cultural pastime. So usually it's not been "divide and conquer" but "we divide - they conquered".

"The Thackerays of this land must be treated like the leper that they are, but there's no action in that regard from the Congress front, which controls the fed govt of this fetid land."

I guess the BJP too controlled the fed govt. and the "thackerays" were their allies. Look why blame only the parties and politicians .... that is the easy answer .... haven't the high and mighty of Mumbai not touched the feet of THE THACKERAY sometime or the other .... hasn't the "marathi manoos" provided legitimacy.
Arun Maheshwari
Bangalore, India
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
10
"The crisis in Maharashtra cannot be handled by making diversity a bedrock value. Rather the bedrock value of our society ought to be freedom: the freedom to call any place in the country home, the freedom to alter culture, the freedom subject to practical constraints, to speak any language, the freedom to break out of the fetter of compulsory identities. Out of this freedom new diversities and cultural forms will emerge. But at the moment the discourse on diversity fails in significant ways: it is too compatible with the imposition and preservation of compulsory identities, and too compatible with the idea that each Indian has his appropriate place whether by virtue of geography or kinship. Tocqueville once defined democracy as being a society to the effect that where you are going matters more than where you came from. In this sense identity talk of the kind we are seeing in Maharashtra and the responses to it are deeply anti-democratic." (Pratap Bhanu Mehta)


http://www.indianexpress.com/story/274166._.html
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
9
Shiva/Bodepudi,

>> Islamic Jihad in India.

Your quota of hate messages for the day is not over yet! You have posted this message in six different article columns! You are making a mockery of this forum. But why should a debased psychopath like you care?
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
8
>> Cong tied up with this Raj Thakeray during the last elections in Maha?

Raj Thackerey had associated himself with the Congress in Pune elections. I do not know of any other collusion between the two.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
7
Maybe he's just a good-natured naieve soul who always prefers to see the glass half-full rather than half-emepty, or he's just your usual contrartian, or perhaps he's gullible enough to believes that Cong is secular or perhaps he has his own agenda in defending the Nehru-owned Congress Party - maybe he thinks that reflexively defending them will show he too is a dyed-in-the wool secularists, this Faruki sa'ab. Or is there something else at play here? Unless I've heard wrong, Cong tied up with this Raj Thakeray during the last elections in Maha?
Bodh
Springfield, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
6
>> The champion of secularism, and here they are, consorting with exactly such communalists for the sake of power.

What is the evidence of the Congress consorting with Raj Thackerey? He was arrested and charged, wasn't he? It took them a couple of days, but it was a politically charged situation. Arrests on charges of incitement to hatred are not as urgent as on charges of, say, murder.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 18, 2008 12:00 AM
5
Divide and conquer - the mantra of every two-bit opportunist who've invaded and ruled this poor, balkanized misgotten land. The Thackerays of this land must be treated like the leper that they are, but there's no action in that regard from the Congress front, which controls the fed govt of this fetid land.
Playing politics is more important to Cong than the security and unity of their country. Yesssirr, wielding power is the only concern of this venal, power-hungry Cong, even if that means bedding down with dung-eating 'communal' carrion the likes of this vile Thackeray - this same Cong which has brayed themselves hoarse on their being The champion of secularism, and here they are, consorting with exactly such communalists for the sake of power. How low they they go? Go ask Lalu, Maya et al.
Bodh
Springfield, United States
Feb 17, 2008 12:00 AM
4
Shiva/Bodepudi,

>> Al-Ghazzawi (whose name means "from Gaza") urges the Palestinians to participate in the war against "the unbelievers, headed by the U.S., Europe and Iran" who are attacking Islam.

This has been the evil standard Al Qaeda slogan for the past 15 years. Why are you getting excited about it now?

>> CAIR openly supports these terrorists in the US, and Ghulam Faruki can not conceal it.

How does an idiot like you explain the fact the CAIR functions openly in the United States, has been challenging the actions of the US military academies and even the actions of the FBI, and that all contributions to CAIR are still tax deductible? CAIR's activities in civic advocacy have been showing success after success. Thanks for giving me the opportunity to make this plug on behalf of CAIR.

Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 17, 2008 12:00 AM
3
>> "It is one of the miracles of Indian civilisation that all of them (Migrant workers) have been accepted peacefully by the host populations. But the opportunity they present to unscrupulous politicians for ephemeral political gain is too great to resist forever."

Our politicians will exploit whatever will bring them votes, irrespective of whether their actions cause national divisiveness or human suffering.

>> "And isn't racial bigotry a blood brother of religious bigotry?"

It certainly is. The latter is actively fostered and openly spurred by the VHP which has a presence in almost every town and village in many states.
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Feb 17, 2008 12:00 AM
2
After examining the drama for last few days I am of the view that Raj Thakeray was not the only culprit.I was very well supported by Congress and to some extent by BJP in order to weaken Shiv Sena.Regional parties who are trying to make foothold in Mahrashtra Politics riding on the back of North Indian should not do anything to jeopardise the very interest of these people.
CA Atul P.Shukla
Allahabad, India
Feb 16, 2008 12:00 AM
1
" Aren't Sonia Gandhi and Manmohan Singh staunch defenders of secularism?"

Who said so???
Ganesan
Nj, USA
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY