Tribhuvan Tiwari
Sacha Sauda chief Gurmeet Ram Rahim who in an ad was shown dressed like Gobind Singh, and stirring a pot of amrit like the guru did three centuries ago
sikhism: threat of the deras
The Morphed Gene
Their more inclusive, less conservative aspect roils Sikhism
punjab
Religion becomes ugly politics in the battle between the minders and the modifiers of the faith
Losing Their Religion?
  • There are an estimated 9,000 deras in Punjab, each headed by a baba or a sant
  • Dera Sacha Sauda is among the largest, with 40 lakh followers
  • About 80 per cent of Punjab's population patronises these deras, which are believed to corner 90 per cent of religious donations in the state today
  • All political parties woo the deras, which can influence large numbers of voters.
     
     
    One baba even wrote his own granth, and asked his followers to burn the scriptures.
     
     
    In the recent assembly poll, the Congress' 12 seats in Malwa are credited to Dera Sacha Sauda
  • The deras sprang up in the aftermath of militancy, and their spiritual heads amassed enormous wealth when they got funds to rebuild gurudwaras
  • They make a special effort to woo lower-caste and illiterate Sikhs, and project an inclusive image
  • Deras now pose a major threat and challenge to the Sikh religious establishment

***

At Kahna Dhesian near Jalandhar, Punjab, all roads lead to a brightly painted gurudwara, every inch of its walls covered in hues of turquoise, red, yellow and green. Though it houses the mandatory Guru Granth Sahib, it lies in a neglected room in a corner of the quadrangle. Pride of place instead is given to a throne-like gaddi where even in the absence of the resident baba, the faithful bow their heads and touch the seat in reverence and obeisance. But this gurudwara, called the dera, and thousands such across the state, are raising the hackles of the Sikh community. The recent violent clashes across Punjab between followers of the influential Dera Sacha Sauda and various Sikh groups reflect the community's growing fears that the 'dera culture' poses the most serious threat yet to their 500-year-old religion.

"In a religion where shabad or the word of God (immortalised in the Guru Granth Sahib) is the guru, there is no place for a living guru or baba or sant," says Dr Jasbir Singh Ahluwalia, Sikh scholar and director of the Guru Gobind Singh Foundation. "This is against the basic tenet of the faith which is steadily being eroded by a mushroom growth of deras in the last decade or so." Analysts estimate that there are about 9,000-odd deras in Punjab today, servicing its 12,329 villages. And, they are patronised by about 80 per cent of the population in Punjab. Prof H.S. Dilgeer, formerly with the Shiromani Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC), points out that "around 90 per cent of the religious offerings are being cornered by deras nowadays". But what is worrying the Sikh religious establishment more is the distortion of the faith, the growing apostasy and the huge following that deras command.


Baba Kashmira Singh has Hindu, Sikh, Christian, Muslim shrines atop his dera

At Jalandhar, Baba Kashmira Singh runs the lucrative Jan Sewa Trust where apart from doling out spiritual advice he also runs a multi-speciality hospital. He preaches unity of all religions and has set up little shrines representative of Hinduism, Sikhism, Christianity and Islam on his dera's rooftop. In 1999, the baba, himself a Sikh, was summoned to the Akal Takht, the supreme spiritual body of the Sikhs, to explain why he should not be excommunicated from the faith for his 'heretical' activities. Kashmira Singh, known for his proximity to the Congress, told Outlook, "Sikhs are breaking away from gurudwaras and coming to deras like mine for spiritual guidance because of their disillusionment with Sikhism. I am not against Sikhs cutting their hair. I believe a religion should be flexible and change with the times." At Kirpal Sagar, a sprawling complex spread over 35 hectares in Rahon village of Nawanshahr district, the piece de resistance is a boat-shaped monument bearing different religious symbols situated in the centre of a rippling tank of water. Here the caretaker of the deceased baba's inheritance is Bibi Surinder Kaur who tells us that amrit in Punjab can only be found at two places. "One at the Golden Temple sarovar in Amritsar, and the other at our dera!" If this rankles the Sikh clergy, the allegedly blasphemous activities of some other deras is a source of frequent violence in the state.

Followers of the controversial Divya Jyoti Jagaran Sansthan at Noormahal run by Ashutosh Maharaj have had several serious runins with Sikh groups who object to the 'samagams' held by the dera all over Punjab, where besides projecting himself as a reincarnation of the Sikh gurus, Ashutosh is allegedly also critical of mainstream Sikhism. In 1998, Baba Piara Bhaniarewala provoked Sikhs by writing his own granth, which he called the Bhavsagar Samundar Granth, and encouraged followers to burn copies of Sikh scriptures. He was excommunicated from the faith by the Akal Takht, but the resultant violence at his dera near Ropar forced the government to provide him a hefty security cover. Notwithstanding the opposition, both the deras have grown in strength and influence.


Ashutosh Maharaj of Divya Jyoti Jagaran Sansthan is critical of mainstream Sikhism

In the rising din against deras, the Sikh clergy, represented by the five Sikh head priests as well as the SGPC, is being squarely blamed for "letting down the faithful". "Our religious leadership has submitted to politicians, and devotes more time to politicking than propagating the religion. Their grip over the people has loosened, and deras and babas have just stepped in to fill the gap," says Prof Darshan Singh, professor emeritus, Guru Nanak Studies, Punjab University. In 2005, around 100 Sikh organisations gathered at the Akal Takht to find ways to check the rising dera cult in Punjab. But due to lack of unanimity over the deras against which action was being contemplated, the campaign fizzled out.

Faced with increasing criticism, the Sikh clergy is on the defensive. Recognising the deras as a "serious threat to Sikhism", Akal Takht jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti believes they are drawing people "because following a baba is easy. There is no need to study or understand the scriptures, or the 'vaani' of gurus. All you have to do is hand over all your worries to the baba, and he takes care of everything. Unfortunately, people do not realise that this is not Sikhism. There is no place for miracle cures, rituals or godmen in our religion." Says SGPC president Avtar Singh Makkar, "We are trying to bring such babas into our fold. But many are misusing the gurbani for their own commercial motives and we are directly in confrontation with them."

The SGPC also claims to have held 'amrit chakho' camps in the last two years in which over a lakh Sikhs have been baptised. Alarmed over the growing number of 'apostates' in the faith, several Sikh missionary organisations too have stepped up their campaigns in rural Punjab, many of them sponsored by wealthy NRI Sikhs. But is it a losing battle? Already more than 80 per cent of Sikh men in rural Punjab do not sport 'kesh' or hair, the most visible symbol of Sikhism. Have deras then sounded the death-knell of Sikhism as we have known it?

"Sikhism is already a dying religion. The basic ethos is gone from it," notes Joginder Singh, editor of daily newspaper Spokesman, and an outspoken critic of the Sikh clergy, for which offence he has been excommunicated from the Sikh panth. Many believe that the sudden rise of deras in Punjab has much to do with the aftermath of militancy in Punjab when many gurudwaras were rebuilt through kar seva or voluntary effort. "This became a racket as many kar seva babas sprung up to take on contract work from the SGPC. They collected huge sums from the public and bought expensive cars for themselves, spending just a fraction of it on the project," says a disgusted Dr Ahluwalia. Many of the deras are now being run by these very kar seva babas who have assumed cult status as godmen of sorts. Their appeal also lies in their inclusive approach. With the caste system rearing its head in Punjab in recent years, its manifestation visible in separate gurudwaras for Dalits and other lower-caste Sikhs, the deras attract this segment with their egalitarianism. It's not surprising that most major deras draw the low castes, the illiterate and the gullible.

If Sikh scholars are alarmed by the growing influence and power of deras, it is because they have established close links with the political fraternity. In the recently concluded Punjab assembly elections, Dera Sacha Sauda came out openly in support of the Congress and constituted district-level political affairs wings. Much of the Congress' good showing in the Malwa belt of Punjab (where the dera has some 10 lakh followers) was to Sacha Sauda's credit, which managed to bring 12-odd seats into the Congress kitty. In return, the party reportedly promised to help out dera head Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh with a CBI enquiry he is facing in the murder of a follower and a journalist, who spilled the beans about sexual exploitation of the dera's woman inmates. Significantly, soon after the polls, the CBI officer enquiring into these allegations was transferred.

Politicians of all hues patronise the deras. "It's a vicious circle," says SGPC member Dr Kiranjot Kaur. "Drawn by their following, politicians go to deras for votes, and their presence grants the dera legitimacy, adding to its following." So it is with Baba Kashmira Singh or Ashutosh Maharaj: they enjoy considerable clout with political parties and use it for their own commercial ends. Currently, chief minister Parkash Singh Badal, whose Akali Dal got a drubbing in its Malwa stronghold thanks to Sacha Sauda, is wooing select deras in the state.

A few years ago, some prominent dera heads organised themselves into the Sant Samaj, an outfit comprising some 350 major deras. Since the SGPC is controlled by the Shiromani Akali Dal, the Sant Samaj became identified with the Congress. This spawned conspiracy theories which held that deras have been deliberately thrust upon Punjabis to dilute Sikhism. But Jathedar Vedanti feels it's unfair to "blame anyone else for what is our own failing". Next week the Delhi Sikh Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee is organising a World Sikh Conclave on the theme, 'How to Save the Sikh Religion'. The battle to do so is already on, and will likely be long-drawn-out.

 

 

punjab
Religion becomes ugly politics in the battle between the minders and the modifiers of the faith
 
Daily MailPublished
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Jun 07, 2007 12:00 AM
7
If the recent 'troubles' are a way for the Khalistani faction to raise anew their head, one may ask why the Hindu community cannot question the use of the upadhi "Vedanti" by the jathedar of Harmandir Sahib. What does it imply attached to his name? That he is a follower of any one of the 10 Vedanta schools generally recognized in classical literature? Or, that by calling himself Vedanti, he is suggesting that the Sikh religion supercedes the Vedas?


In any case, his assumption of an orthodox Hindu cognomen deserves investigation and scrutiny. Might its use not be compared to the Dera person's assumption of a mantle to which he was not entitled?


Pray pardon me for bringing up an older topic that also has me seething. That is Smruti Koppikar's writing on the issue of a young Muslim man aged around 20 eloping with a Hindu teenager around 15, with whom he had been sexually involved for at least 3 years prior to their eloping. Smruti is horrified that the Muslim community did nothing to defend its young man; read her words.


I am simply amazed at Smruti's absence of any sense, and Vinod Mehta's lack of editorial advice. For me, this is not a question of Hindu or Muslim. This is a case of "STATUTORY RAPE" as defined by the law: a male who has reached adulthood having a relationship with a minor female, and that too from a very early age.


Smruti, can you please answer me this: if your daughter aged 12 was having sex with your employee aged 17-18, would you be comfortable? So if he were a Muslim, would you advocate the elders of the community to quit their cowardice and rise up and defend his right to run off with your daughter when she was 15 years old? Try that on for size.
Substitute Hindu, Buddhist, Christian, Jain, Animist, Wiccan, whatever, for the boy, and try each: are you still content?


Vinod, in your hatred for Hindus and Hinduism, have you gone quite out of your mind to publish such obscenity by this madwoman? I have never felt so sickened by Outlook's and Frontline's prejudices as I was by this article.


vamadeva bhatttacharya
ithaca, United States
May 27, 2007 12:00 AM
6
YOu say 80 % of punjabs population subscribes to these deras, have you carried out a survey or have you thought of the fact maybe its just your gut feeling tthta says that such a mass must be subscribing to the deras. The Sikh population in punjab wether they would like to keep there kes or not but they would still be sikh in the hearts. 70 % of all the sikhs setttled abroad have cut there hairs but still belive in the sikh religion and pay millions of dollars worth of donations to the gurdwaras, how many of these give to the deras if 80 % of there families had subscribed to the deras. I dont think that many and if such a large population would have belived in te deras it would probably have been the sikh on th reciving end rather then the deras. So please get your facts right.
Paramjit
Delhi, India
May 22, 2007 12:00 AM
5
"Since the SGPC is controlled by the Shiromani Akali Dal..."

This says it all. When the top religious institutiion of sikhism itself is involved in partisan politics, it is inevitable that other political/religious combinations will also spring up, in this case congress/deras combine.

When a religion becomes too politically ambitious, it cannot provide the spiritual guidance to its followers, which was why it came into existance in the first place. Hence, the various sects and groups start coming to the fore. It's the same story with most religions, be it hinduism, christianity or islam. Buddhism too has different sects, but is still far less politicized than other major religions of the world.
kunal
denver, usa
May 22, 2007 12:00 AM
4
This is first article I have read that gives me insights into the reasons behind this very shameful episode of extreme and sometimes violent reaction by some Sikhs.
The deras' principle of including everyone is a great one but I was disillusioned to read that many of its leaders are being investigated for criminal activities themselves.
I think the message for the common man in India is this: Be aware of the priests who preach hatred and violence but also of "gurus" or anyone who says he has more knowledge/wisdom than the common man. We all should follow common sense and that should never fail us.
vijay
arlington, United States
May 21, 2007 12:00 AM
3
Nature is ruthlessly efficient doesnot have any regard for that which , in its eyes, has lost its use / efficiency and removes it from existence however, exalted and useful it might have been in the past.
satish chander
Mumbai, India
May 20, 2007 12:00 AM
2
Sword wielding sikhs should not be allowed to take law and order into their hands. Religions should not cross its lakshman rekha.
State and centre should protect innocent citizens from akalis.
Chitralekha
Panipat, India
May 20, 2007 12:00 AM
1
"They make a special effort to woo lower-caste and illiterate Sikhs, and project an inclusive image"

- The answer to "How to save Sikhism" lies here.
Raj
Chicago, United States
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY