R. Prasad
opinion
The Deeper Pattern
Tuesday's attacks had LeT's imprint. India, Pakistan can lose no more time.
mumbai blasts
...India falls. You and I know this. Unfortunately, so do the terrorists, the bearded fanatics who run Lashkar-e-Toiba, SIMI and Al Qaeda
Vinod Mehta
mumbai blasts
Seven bombs rip through the city's lifeline. It still staves off civic chaos but how much more can its people take?
Smruti Koppikar
The train of events that ripped the city's lifeline
suburban railways
Placing bombs on local trains is child's play. Security checks on them is zilch.
Smruti Koppikar
investigation
Maharashtra clearly muffed up in probing activity in Tier II towns
Smruti Koppikar
simi
Is the outfit a handy name to bandy about or the local face of foreign terrorists?
Bhavna Vij-Aurora
INTELLIGENCE
Lack of experienced heads has left the agencies demoralised and directionless
Saikat Datta
Kashmir blasts
Kashmir's tourism sector is the target, with local boys as pawns
Zafar Meraj
indo-pak relations
The latest round of acrimony could endanger the peace process
Mariana Baabar
indo-pak relations
If the situation is allowed to drift, positions may harden
V. Sudarshan
pakistan
Pakistan's crackdown on militants is nominal, they're still flourishing
Amir Mir
impact/economy
Markets are by now unaffected by terror's ways. But it extracts a long-term price.
Saumya Roy
No terrorist group has claimed responsibility yet for the murder of about 200 civilians in Mumbai, or the string of five attacks on tourists in Srinagar last Tuesday. This is par for the course. In 17 years of violence in Kashmir, insurgents and crossborder 'guests' have taken credit only for attacks on the security forces. When they kill civilians they remain silent or try to shift the blame on the government. But both attacks bear the imprint of the Lashkar-e-Toiba (LeT): In Mumbai, it was multiple, closely synchronised explosions to maximise shock and anger. In Srinagar, tourists were targeted in synchronised attacks in a bid to disrupt the huge revival of tourism that has taken place in the past two years.

These are not random attacks. Nor are they unconnected. Tuesday's attack in Mumbai was the fifth in eight months. Their strategic purpose is to trigger a communal bloodbath in India in which thousands of Muslims are killed in 'reprisal' killings such as those of Gujarat. The first was made upon shoppers in Delhi, last Diwali, when a string of explosions killed 52 people and injured more than two hundred. The second was the string of blasts in and around the temples of Varanasi. The third was the selective killing of 35 Hindus in Doda—the first such act in seven years even in that troubled part of Jammu and Kashmir. The fourth was the fidayeen attack on the RSS headquarters at Nagpur. Had the fidayeen not gone to the wrong building, they might have killed scores of senior RSS cadres who were participating in a 1,000-cadre summer training camp being held at its training centre (sometimes mistaken for its headquarters), not far away. Tuesday's attack in Mumbai was the fifth in this series.

The attacks in Srinagar were the second of their kind in six weeks. The first was a string of three grenade attacks on Gujarati and Bengali tourists in Srinagar towards the beginning of June. These led to an exodus of more than a thousand tourist buses from the Valley and the cancellation of thousands of bookings. This second attack, on another Bengali tour bus, on a car with a Haryana number plate, and on tourists at the tourist reception centre, seems designed to complete the job.

All the previous attacks, except the one on the tourists in June, have been traced back to the LeT. Even before Tuesday's outrages they had begun forming a disturbing pattern. President Musharraf publicly abandoned the Pakistani dream of annexing Kashmir when he proposed a federal Kashmir with something less than full sovereignty and accepted Dr Manmohan Singh's suggestion that the solution to the Kashmir dispute lay not in redrawing borders but making them irrelevant. This left zealots like the LeT only one way of reversing the 'surrender'—to trigger a communal bloodbath in India through calculated attacks on Hindus, making it impossible for Kashmiris to feel safe in India. Had the fidayeen managed to penetrate the RSS training camp at Nagpur, they may have succeeded.

India may again prove lucky. Even though the death toll has already risen to around 200 in Mumbai, these attacks, too, may not succeed in triggering the kind of riots we saw after the burning of the Sabarmati Express in 2002. But we must now face the possibility that the LeT will continue to mount such murderous attacks till the patience of the Hindus finally snaps—although they are never exclusively the victims in such mass-scale terror—and communal riots ensue. It would be idle to pretend that Tuesday's attacks have not changed the parameters of the India-Pakistan dialogue for the worse. The abortive attack on the RSS headquarters had already forced Dr Manmohan Singh to abandon his plans to go to Islamabad. If the attacks in the heartland of India continue, he will come under immense pressure to take some form of pre-emptive action. The least that pressure will do is put an end to the rapprochement between India and Pakistan.

Pakistan obviously does not want this, for an increase in tension with India would force it to redeploy troops from Waziristan and Balochistan. That would pose a dire threat to its territorial integrity. General Musharraf has, therefore, condemned the attacks in the strongest possible terms. But the LeT and its associates will not be stopped by words alone. Pakistan must, therefore, do more. The simplest and most convincing proof of its sincerity would be for it to share intelligence on the LeT's plans to perpetrate outrages in mainland India with the Indian government. New Delhi also needs to see that if the LeT is doing all it can to prevent a meeting between Dr Manmohan Singh and General Musharraf, then postponing such a meeting indefinitely will crown it with success. Perhaps, the time has come for Dr Manmohan Singh to dispense with intermediaries and at least speak to the general directly on the phone. Both the governments need to face this threat together.

(The author's columns can be read at www.premshankarjha.com)
mumbai blasts
...India falls. You and I know this. Unfortunately, so do the terrorists, the bearded fanatics who run Lashkar-e-Toiba, SIMI and Al Qaeda
Vinod Mehta
mumbai blasts
Seven bombs rip through the city's lifeline. It still staves off civic chaos but how much more can its people take?
Smruti Koppikar
The train of events that ripped the city's lifeline
suburban railways
Placing bombs on local trains is child's play. Security checks on them is zilch.
Smruti Koppikar
investigation
Maharashtra clearly muffed up in probing activity in Tier II towns
Smruti Koppikar
simi
Is the outfit a handy name to bandy about or the local face of foreign terrorists?
Bhavna Vij-Aurora
INTELLIGENCE
Lack of experienced heads has left the agencies demoralised and directionless
Saikat Datta
Kashmir blasts
Kashmir's tourism sector is the target, with local boys as pawns
Zafar Meraj
indo-pak relations
The latest round of acrimony could endanger the peace process
Mariana Baabar
indo-pak relations
If the situation is allowed to drift, positions may harden
V. Sudarshan
pakistan
Pakistan's crackdown on militants is nominal, they're still flourishing
Amir Mir
impact/economy
Markets are by now unaffected by terror's ways. But it extracts a long-term price.
Saumya Roy
 
Daily Mail
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Aug 09, 2006 12:00 AM
25
The New York Times' report : "India Fears Terrorism May Attract Its Muslims"


http://tinyurl.com/rket3
Ghulam Y Faruki
New York, United States
Jul 22, 2006 12:00 AM
24
The writer is bending over backwards to support Pakistani political/military leaders.
The matter is very simple.If India keeps quite,this will continue.We can expect many hundreds of terrorist attacks more.
The best solution for this is counter attack.
K.V.Sadasivan
Bharuch, India
Jul 21, 2006 12:00 AM
23
Not only the English media... All Language scribes in India claim and declare that all these concerted attacks are for provoking a riot. This's absoulte ridiculous. In case of any such backlash, don't the terrorists know that there'll be more Muslim body bags than that of Hindus and also there'll be an uprising from the Hindus united against Islamic extremism, as is currently in Gujarat after the riots. There's no logical reasoning whatsoever by anyone in the country on why in the world these rogues would want a riot happening against their own community. If at all that were their intentions, why shouldn't they attack a big Mosque, which'll obviously & immediately make Muslims run on streets like hell.

Though it's a good tactic to stop such happening by our Politicos and Media, It's demoralising & scaring the people by repeatedly saying this fictious intention and is an insult to the people and the Nation as a whole.
Narayan
Zurich, Switzerland
Jul 20, 2006 12:00 AM
22
This is the reason why none in the world respects us or sympethises with us when it comes to terrorism. Inspite of having an year full of bomb blasts, same as US/UK/Indonesia combined, we have barely heard a peep in U8 summit. If we are deluding ourselves and living in dreamland saying Musharraf is the saint, then why should other countries bother condemn the instigators. Its not their citizens dying.
Vindi
San Diego, United States
Jul 19, 2006 12:00 AM
21
It's Disgusting to read the chiding remarks US commented about India, which should be mainly attributed to the spine-less response to the crisis by this coward country. What's even more infuriating is it's praising the Terror state even now and it's pain in atleast recognizing India as one of the terror affected countries.
If at all US had learnt completely the nature of our p-sec politicos and media, it might have even suggested that it's not at all a handi-work of Islamic militants.!!!
Narayan
Zurich, Switzerland
Jul 19, 2006 12:00 AM
20
Next time I see Jha I am going to give him a hard kick on his Musharraf(i.e.posterior)for this dirty old man is anti-national pure and simple...This scum's writings show what some people can do for money(which he gets from Pakistan)...His PR exercise for pakistan is so blatantly obvious that it makes any patriotic Indian puke...as I said next time I see him I will....and I will have no regret for kicking his Musharraf for this man who has even sold his soul for a pittance...bloody traitor if you ask me
Abhimanyu
Mumbai, India
Jul 19, 2006 12:00 AM
19
The way Jha and Mehta write I wonder how much Musharraf pays them to be their mouthpiece. Considering the junk they dispense, i am sure it would be peanuts.
Rajeev
Delhi, India
Jul 19, 2006 12:00 AM
18
Lalit Bagai wrote: "Like wise it our karma to listen to such bumbling idiots like MMS, the holy ghost and her chamchas."

"In the last instance many of us read this paper for free. And we express our feelings freely.
That in some ways exonerates Outlook for its many faults and lies."

The above quotes are funny and insightful.
Prasanth
Cochin, India
Jul 19, 2006 12:00 AM
17
This rogue Jha really want us to believe that LET & Pakistan are seperate entities. That's what this whole article is about, trying to protect the terrorist regime in Islamabad. The point Jha is trying to make is, let's not blame Musharaaf until he is personally involved in blasts or terror attacks across India. Now, why would a general do things by himself when he has ISI and other terror outfits under his command. Jha knows that very well. So he will continue to isolate Musharaaf all the time. India is the only country in the world where the journalist community write these kinds of articles propogating dismemberment of their motherland. These journalists should be put behind bars for treason & inciting terrorism against India. They should be exposed and humiliated. They should be socially boycotted.

Bring Modi to the center stage. India needs him. Hindus masses need him.


Visit www.hinduunity.org

Indian Secularist
Chicago, United States
Jul 19, 2006 12:00 AM
16
Dear Prem shankerjee, there are many good points in your article which our spineless politicians can think off.Indias problem in tackling the islamic terrorism is the laxity of internal security.Its foolish to search for the thief when he is one amongst ourselves.we have to and can devise the anti terror strategy on simple terms.A special court only to try terror related cases,speedy and fast track disposals and severe punishments are the basic needs.along with that huge spending on the sealing of the borders as well as more surveillance on the airports.new high tech immigration laws,new and foolproof electronic passport or additional idenetification with digital signatures and its databse etc.The political will in the interest of the nation and the training from the school level how to face the treats and dangers of the terrorism,end to vote bank compulsions will go a long way in decimating the islamic terrorism.Its not important who is behind and who carried out the blasts but the intentions that are the vital clues to nab the culprits.since as you said these islamic terrorist very cleverly own or disown the responsibilty of the crime they commit as how it suits them.If we analyse the mumbai train blasts even a ignorant person could say if one goes by the modus operandi that its not a terrorist attack but a sheer targetted killings of the hindus.Well, when we have people in this country including some media who are trying to blame the victims itself as responsible for the perpetrators act and this is usual and nothing new in india .thats why we see how the politicians and the media adverse to the hindu interest groups accuse them of communalising the mumbi blasts for thier narrow ends.Dont you think that our politicians will go to the extent of mocking at the dead bodies by saying so.though the victms are dead but its not impossible that they will rise from the ashes.
vinod
Bangalore, India
Jul 19, 2006 12:00 AM
15
It is the karma of the middle classes in India to read the arbage presented by the secular journalist

Like wise it our karma to listen to such bumbling idiots like MMS, the holy ghost and her
chamchas.

Frankly both of these are worse then any terrorist attack.

What has surprised me is the attitude of the newspaper owners. Are they anti national or just illiterate. They have passed on control of their papers to some of the most unscrupulous scoundrels, who will sell their country for
a bottle of scotch.

Insults are showered on them,but it makes no difference to them. They are ready with their weekly crap.

What will meke them stop.
lalit bagai
kalundborg, Brazil
Jul 19, 2006 12:00 AM
14
Jha should lose no more time to cross over to Pakistan and acquire Pakistani citizenship pronto...
Abhimanyu
Mumbai, India
Jul 18, 2006 12:00 AM
13
shivkumar...why do you doubt...whom the vinod mehta's and Jha's suckle from is but obvious.
vedant
Bangalore, India
Jul 17, 2006 12:00 AM
12
Diplomacy and Propaganda at it's best.


http://www.ndtv.com/tem...lid=1&category=National


Despite being the perpetrator look at this rogue state's outburst. We cowards deserve this further humiliation that too at the hands of the very perpetrator for our Zero action on a National crisis and a spineless reaction to this terror state.
Narayan
Zurich, Switzerland
Jul 17, 2006 12:00 AM
11
I guess Mr. Jha must be one of the few people who still has immense belief in the double speaking General.
The General will never dismantle the terror camps as US has only now started realizing because they are his bargaining tools. By stopping talks with Pakistan and insisting and building up International pressure to ensure that Pakistan control the terrorists, we will not loose anything but for once would have acted properly and strategically in India's long term intersts.
Navdeep Hans
Delhi, India
Jul 17, 2006 12:00 AM
10
perks of being ` secular` in media and `in-human rights`

1.can shift from any newspaper , channel political party ....according to the convinience and to protect secular fabric..( dunno which factory its made in)...of india

2. can travel all round world ....especially pakistan....and increase your profile by being visible evry where....

3. free travel...stay at five stars...i.e free tourism with all bills paid

4. can apper angel type by criticising nationalism and showing how they care for the ' humanity'

5. of course once u raise your profile u increase ur price for lectures...articles...speeches

6. jha is a old fox at it...so human ....that angels sometimes weep at his words...

it is very easy to be secular in this country and take easy comfortable stands....after all what one loses ....mulayam singh loses nothing by supporting simi
parag
bombay, india
Jul 17, 2006 12:00 AM
9
Mr. Jha I doubt whether you are paid by Pakistan/ISI? There are news from sources that lot of our leading Indian Editors/Journalists/TV Channels and few central ministers/state chief ministers are in the pay role of ISI/Dawood/Pakistan/sheikhs. Whole India knows why you journalists and media become so secular and want peace with Pakistan and always criticize right wing parties. You are telling we should believe in Mushraff and Pakistan. They are like snakes and snakes will never change their basic nature even if you feed milk and make friendship with them, they will bite at the right moment. Pakistan is a rogue State, filled with criminals and fundamentalists. US will not take any action on Pakistan, because without Pakistan, there is no support for US forces in Afghanistan. Only time will tell, whether we can fight the terrorists or wait for more innocent people to be killed.

"Every nation has got the right to protect itself". This was said by Bush when asked about Israel attacking on Lebanon couple of days ago. Will he say the same thing to us? We are no way commanding any respect international community. Our patience is tested and exploited time and again. It is time we give them fitting reply and qualify ourselves as males and men of taking salt.
shivkumar
Mumbai, India
Jul 17, 2006 12:00 AM
8
Brother Ganesan and sister Shivani

I read an article in Pakistan Link written by Dr Shireen Mazar, director general of strategic studies.

She expressed her dislike for India and Hindus openly. We are 2 separate people, with nothing in common. The peace process she said has one purpose only, and that is to get hold of Kashmir.

Journalists of Outlook and other secular journalists have one agenda. To white wash Pakistan, to tarnish the reputation of any Hindus organisation.One may question the reasons behind this. Maybe there are some Indians Hindus who find the muslim way of life more attractive.
Maybe they have something against their own community.

But with their deep irrationality and prejudices they will always take the side of India,s main enemy which is fundamentalist slam and its main seat of power ie Pakistan.

All of us have heard the Jha speak. We are disgusted by this man, We loath everything he stands for. That he continues to express his opinions is because he has the support of the Outlook editor and further down the line of the owners of this magazine.

In the last instance many of us read this paper for free. And we express our feelings freely.
That in some ways exonerates Outlook for its many faults and lies.
lalit bagai
kalundborg, Brazil
Jul 16, 2006 12:00 AM
7
jha uncle is redefining the bounds and heights of optimism. he still believes pak would do something for india.
musharraf has expressed strong codmemnation!!!!! and he belives that... jha has redrawn limits of gullibility too... i would rather trust crocodile's tears than paki's..
bhushan
richmond, United States
Jul 16, 2006 12:00 AM
6
the pshycotic nonsensical pretensious analyst is at it again.

look at him divert the focus from the issue - the mindless attack on a civil population who were going about their daily jobs.

instead...he alludes motives to the act..what about the lives maimed...? whose case is outlook propunding by fielding lousy cheapos of this kind? does this piece of twisted mind have any idea what he is talking about?

india and pakistan should lose no more time...he says so..as if pakistan is eager to get together but isnt being allowed to..?

hafiz mohammed sayeed of LET operates freely in pakistan...masood azhar who was roaming around in pakistan is suddenly nowhere since interpol issued an notice against him, till then pakistan denied he had any involvement in any wrongdoing against india...sheikh omar who was released along with masood was first denied to be in pak...then when he killled daniel pearl he was pulled out like a rabit from a magicians cap by the pakis...there is so much more....

also for this lunatic to propund the motive as communal violence being the aim of the blasts..one has to wonder what level has this man[?] deteriorated...no terrorist attack in india has been followed by communal violence...

if mumbai rioted in 1993 it was because in radhabai chawl and hindu family was locked up from outside and burnt to death...by muslims...

if gujarat rioted it was because a 1000 strong muslim mob in signal falia surrounded the buring coach having 50+ women and children so as to prevent their escape and ensure their incineration...the prime accused in that attack is today in pakistan...and has been claimed to be there by nobody else but the current UPA government...which has authored a report saying that the fire in godhra was a accident....

vinod mehta...u are crossing limits...if it wasnt enough that you published rubbish about 'kanchi shankarachrya's women' you continue to have an agenda which seems to be nothing else but mindless and insulting interpretation [for india] of pakistan and its motives.
vedant
Bangalore, India
Jul 16, 2006 12:00 AM
5
No doubt the secular think tank of india should re-organize its priorities. I am sure this is not going to happen at least in the comming two years as the minority appeasing govt at the center would prevent it.
Wunder
dubai, United Arab Emirates
Jul 16, 2006 12:00 AM
4
Mr Jha

The best you can do for India, is for you to move to Palistan. If this is not possible, because I doubt that the Pakis will want you , then the next best is to stop writeing your usual garbage.

I skim through your posts They make no sense. However I presume they provide you with pocket money.
lalit bagai
kalundborg, Brazil
Jul 15, 2006 12:00 AM
3
Does anyone remember that recently when a BJP leader in J&K announced a reward of one lakh to any citizen who kills a terrorist, the Congress govt. slapped charges against him for inciting communal violence.

Now may of the public feels the same, taking law into their own hands and go after the terrorists themselves because this govt. failed to standup to terroris. Now what is the UPA govt. going to do? Slap charges against the Hindu masses?

Indian Secularist
Chicago, United States
Jul 15, 2006 12:00 AM
2
And more importantly, contrary to the accepted wisdom, I dont think Kashmir is a pressing problem that needs to be solved asap or else....

The status quo works well for India and we can maintain it as long as we want. We can move towards a solution as when the time is right. There is no need to rush to a solution simply for the sake of reaching a solution. India can afford the present impasse while Pak cannot. We must have Reagan's tenacity in dealing with Pak. As he said to Gorbachev" We can outspend you as long as we want and you can never win". The same is true for India as well. While we must do everything to break Pakistan, there is no need to rush for a solution. The present impasse works well for us Kashmir.

Some may think that would keep the terrorists in business for a long time. But resolution of kashmir is not going to put them out of business. They will simply find a new venue. Kashmir is just a pretext for terrorists.
Ganesan
Nj, USA
Jul 15, 2006 12:00 AM
1
"Pakistan obviously does not want this, for an increase in tension with India would force it to redeploy troops from Waziristan and Balochistan.General Musharraf has, therefore, condemned the attacks in the strongest possible terms."

It seems rather strange to exculpate a person on a crime charge based on his condemnation of the crime! Would I be free from justice if I commit a murder and then condemn the muder? The only "proof" Jha has in favour of Musharraf is that he condemned them. But he refuses to see the pattern in his dealings-right from Kargil. He wants to have the cake and eat it also. There is no reason on why we should trust this man or deal with him. There is absolutely no reason why we should bend ourselves and meet this man. All we have to do is to tighten the border, create new tough laws on terrorism and implement them at home and be ruthless in engaging with terrorists. If it means sending covert operatives to POK or PAK, then it must be done and so forth. Musharraf is either behind all this or he is totally incomepetent in stopping them. Either way, he is not a factor in the long run.
Ganesan
Nj, USA
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY