Opinion
The Best Of Worlds
Contrary to popular belief, the vast majority of IITians do nothing of note in their lives...
Cover Story
Near-complete autonomy and a fanatical focus on quality make the IITs the cradle of some of the world's best talent
Shantanu Guha Ray, Neerja Pawha Jetley, Charubala Annuncio, A.S. Panneerselvan, Tin A. Gokhale, Vasantha Arora In New York
Contrary to popular belief, the vast majority of IITians do nothing of note in their lives. Indeed, many of them became IITians because their parents told them that's what they should mug their butts off for, and aim to hit the US of A, so that's what they did. They attended classes, took notes, passed exams, took the gre, applied to a dozen American universities, and disappeared into that country's vast technological underbelly, to reappear only in the matrimonial columns of Indian papers with a dollar salary multiplied diligently by the day's exchange rate. Or they stayed in India, working at unexceptionable jobs, doing reasonably well. In either case, they got beautiful brides (often from rich families) and presumably lived happily ever after, meeting classmates once a month and chatting about their IIT days, and how Hippo has just changed jobs, and Zap is three rungs away from the top in Cisco Systems. Each of them had intelligence well above the average, and most, exceptional academic tenacity.

A decade and a half out of IIT, I wonder how many of us IITians achieved our potential? How many went to seed in remote dusty townships, tending massive pipelines and drinking in the township club? How many wilfully walked away from their natural talents in favour of safe MNC jobs selling diapers and hire-purchase schemes? How many, trained to think rationally and without bias, never managed to figure out the nuances of Indian office politics, and were relegated to obscure corridors in huge buildings? How many, obsessed with the American dream, settled for second-rate US universities, hung in for a green card, and today work at unfulfilling jobs in Idaho?

There's another angle too to this. How many IITians, determined to stay engineers and in India, ignored the siren songs of the USA and the IIMs, and joined Indian industry, only to find that all the technical designs came from abroad, that you couldn't change them even if you knew they were flawed, that all the engineering you got to do was maintenance, and knowing all that, they either settled into mediocrity, or went off to the US or the iims?

What was my IIT education all about? It was about IITians: 400 academically exceptional boys (and 12 girls) on a campus, which, in the case of Kharagpur, where I went, was far enough from civilisation to have very interesting effects on our coming of age. Many of us were truly extraordinary. There were boys from village schools who were leagues ahead in knowledge of the urban convent-educated type. There were those who mugged night and day, or simpered at professors from first benches, and there were those who also had a vibrant and busy life outside academics. I've found that the latter did better in life, even in fields like pure research. I also had friends who never needed to study, they had been apparently born with engineering wisdom in their genes. There were guys who spent most of the semester in a drug haze, but sobered up a few days before the exams, cracked them, and went back to their pharmaceuticals. Others did not have such control. Like Allen Ginsberg, I too saw some of the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness. A few dropped out (I met one of them years later in Shillong, a stridently devout convert to Catholicism, and a lowly government clerk, but he seemed happy), a few killed themselves. But, most of us survived. I suppose we became tougher, more mature, more knowing, and more aware of our dark sides.

We lived and ate together, and shared our joys and heartbreaks and good times and bad times, in competition and camaraderie. We compared our philosophies and, bit by stumbling bit, developed our value systems. Never were stronger bonds forged between young people. Years from now, if I meet an IIT wingmate on the road, I know we will carry on as if nothing had changed, and nothing actually would have. A couple of years ago, there was a small visual trick on an Outlook cover, which was my idea. A close IIT friend, whom I had not been in touch with for years, called up from Singapore: "Some other name is mentioned in the cover credits, but it was your idea, right? I know the way you think." No one knows me better than these mates of mine from IIT.

IIT was also a whole insular world in itself, complex and complete, and it sucked us in. As The Chosen, we lived a full life with no necessity of any contact with the outside world. Totally cut off from politics and "the bigger issues", our delights remained in competing fiercely on the field or the stage with other hostels or other colleges. There were few material pleasures. Lifestyles were spartan, the food abysmal. The vast majority of males were totally deprived of female company. The girls lived a strange life-on the one hand, they were hounded by dozens of would-be suitors; on the other, they faced the petulant hostility of the majority which saw them as undeserving of so much adulation and so many free lunches.

When we graduated, we went out into the world with a rare confidence and strong tribal loyalties. The confidence eroded a bit over the years, and we learnt some humility when we discovered non-IITians as smart as we were, and also people who could outwit us because they were intelligent in a different way-in a sly political way-an acumen we had not developed in our isolated environment which, above all, inculcated a sense of fairness and a respect for ability. We came to terms with a world that compared poorly with our beloved campus, and some of us even went ahead and conquered it. Others didn't do well, but knew that the ties between them and the masters-of-the-universe classmates would never change. They were ties born of the pride of being an IITian. That pride would never diminish.

It never can.


The author, Deputy Editor of Outlook, is an Electronics Engineer from IIT Kharagpur. He also met his wife at IIT.

Cover Story
Near-complete autonomy and a fanatical focus on quality make the IITs the cradle of some of the world's best talent
Shantanu Guha Ray, Neerja Pawha Jetley, Charubala Annuncio, A.S. Panneerselvan, Tin A. Gokhale, Vasantha Arora In New York
 
Daily Mail
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Nov 02, 2009 08:36 AM
27
Congrats Sandipan,
An awsum article.. Loved it all the way.. I can see many people standing against it, i suspect them of being the current students of IITs. Its just their IIT pride speaking ;)

I m sure the moment they graduate, their views will change..
Krishan
New Delhi, India
Oct 30, 2009 09:06 PM
26
Dear Sandipan,
Please get the facts right before writing an article like this.Please do not generalize your views.IITs are supposed to generate top class engineers and they are doing the same.I can assert without any fear of contradiction that IITs are the only engineering colleges in the country who organize various lectures,seminars by most prominent personalities in the country.(We call them EXTRA MURAL LECTURES).IITs organize the country's best tech,cultural festivals completely organized by students.(MOODI,SAARANG,SHAASTRA,TECH FEST).What else do you need to get political ,real world exposure.Coming to academics,if a student is not doing well in his academics its his fault,IITs shouldnt be mistaken for this.You seemed to have a very bad time at KGP.But please realise my friend,its your mistake,not the world renowned IIT's.
chirutha.iitm
hyderabad, India
Oct 29, 2009 02:20 PM
25
this article is seriously flowed
u seem confused , frustrated & unprepared to write this article
sankalp agarwal
kanpur, India
Oct 09, 2009 07:09 PM
24
Tejinder

Please get your facts right. Which Institute doesn't generate careerists? Secondly who told you that thousands of crores of rupees are poured into IITs. Thirdly who told you that world class research isn't going on in IITs. The projects that are going on in here and those which are completed can easily be found out by just using google even the patents. I am an undergraduate student and am working on a technology that is an IIT Kharagpur product. I apologise if my english is faulty. I request you to do thorough research about things you talk about.
Abhishek Biswas
Kharagpur, India
Oct 09, 2009 06:55 PM
23
Maybe what sandeepan has tried to tell us is the case with maximum IIT students. so why doesn't he come forward to help us out. I mean I am still undecided what to do when I pass out and there are a hell lot of people who feel the same way as I do. We come here, we study and we get our degree but we don't have a freaking idea about the area we can excel in. The bit about settling with a beautiful wife and a handsome salary, isn't it the dream of alomst every person in India? Tell me how many people are out there to take up responsibilities and face some challenges. I would like to ask Sandeepan who is the deputy chief editor. Are you doing what you wanted to do in the first place? If yes I would be really very happy for you. It seems You want us IITians to be pioneers. The article IS a bit confusing though. Now to do something big we need cold hard cash. Where the hell is it going to come from. Either we do some business on our own I mean like starting really small or look for sponsors. I hope you understand what I mean if not I would elaborate but later. Money doesn't come cheap. It never has. No one will give it away just like that until and unless it has something in it for him. And about reaching our full potential. Do you really think its that easy. Even in our institute we are not allowed to use our own full proof methods in exams. As if the outside world is sitting just to accept our ideas. Its not a strategy game but a real world out there which if put as a function has a thousand variables and the function is damn difficult to solve. There is a saying "Just because you can doesn't mean you have to". It applies to you too. You felt something and you wrote an article which is an instant success but you didn't think much about it which is very clear. This is all I have to say if anyone wants to differ please let it known here.
Abhishek Biswas
Kharagpur, India
Oct 09, 2009 12:24 AM
22
There was a man in front of his house there was dump yard...Every time when dump was thrown by other people he used to shout at them but in nights he used to throw the dump himself at the same place but he didn't want other people to place the dump there..Nobody stopped neither the man nor the people..They laughed behind his back...Did you get the moral?...Its simple blame yourself not the system and keep the unity and +ive thought's about what else can be added to IIT's to get her to the level of MIT's or more....Let me tell you if you are an IITian who you really are..Let's forget about what you became inside of IIT for a moment(not to mention we became truly us inside the campus)......You are still at a position about what more then a million students every night dreamed of to be.....And you want that dream to meet its your way of reality which ain't true either....Because comparatively IIT's are better until you went thru a private college of engg in india...You know how many pvt institution are there for engg in india?..And more over satisfaction does not come easily no matter whatever you pick to do,either its career or whatever..Its human nature of getting bore ASAP with almost everything..Until unless you stick to something on your own or you are forced to..Having something in hand and then making your dreams come true will be better then having nothing and keep on struggling...There are a lot many ppl who have changed the career after being techie for certain years....All everybody want is an MIT or "Choice of Career with a 100 million population" in india right away,instead of being thankful with what we got,we are blaiming something which was truly ours...Can you tell me the step's of development for that..Is it overnight?..Dude we are "Developing" not "Developed"..The only lag among us is the realization of the position we are at...Whom to blame you tell me yourself...If yourself didn't realize what have you done you can't expect from anyone else too...Nobody can blaim the system until he tried...Come back open a institution and try your best,we all will be waiting to give you a hand bro...
Mayank
bangalore, India
Oct 08, 2009 10:38 PM
21
Mayank

I am touched by your faith and your aspirations for the idea of India. Unfortunately, I think IITs are a scam perpetuated on innocent Indians the like of you. My personal opinion is that the thousands of crores of tax payer rupees spent every year are not worth the kind of output we are getting from these institutes. What is more, this implicit hierarchy automatically encourages the deprivation of other Engineering Institutes whose students are equally good, if not better, than these that carry the IIT brand. I understand that as Indians, we implicitly try to put things in terms of pecking order. Maybe this is a hangover of thousands of years of caste system, maybe not. However this is definitely not a trend we would want to encourage. Now, if there were patents and world class publications coming out by the hundreds, if not thousands, from these institutes, I would be the first to say they are centers of excellence. However, this is not the case. The author himself admits that most students, once they get in, are not interested in their Engineering studies. It is just a first step to ‘better’ things. I would even go on to say that the academic environment is 'anti-intellectual'. A perverted snobbery constantly drums into you the division of the world in two spheres, the IITians and the non-IITians. This is completely contrary to the demands of academic excellence and inquiry, whose very first requirements are humility and openness. This scandalous, enforced elitism that is so out of touch with the reality of a poor nation like ours can only generate disgust for both the philosophy as well as for those who so consistently espouse it for their own career advancement. I am sorry to disappoint you but IITs mostly just generate careerists, not the kind of well rounded humane visionaries that most Indians like you expect them to.
tejinder
st louis, United States
Oct 08, 2009 04:03 PM
20
My comments are specially for "tejinder
st louis, United States" and to author for some other idea's where I strongly disagree..
Mayank
bangalore, India
Oct 08, 2009 03:41 PM
19
With each slice of Food you take,every moment of breathing which gives you a moment long to live you should thank your Nation for that.You were selected for the IIT's because they still believe that you might be the part of a Vision the intelligent people saw long back.Do you think they are stupid to get you in, if you think so then its not them , Its you.No where in a world the Training Scenario matches the reality of world.Every time you are just taught how to swim/fight and some lessons about sea/river or a terrorist encounter...But its upto you and your will how good fight you can give..If you'll not evolute you'll not survive but you are IITian some how you'll because your degree is there to hold your bread in your hands because even you don't believe but people still have faith in you that you are different.And you are denying that you are just nobody.How stupid!..Blaiming other brother IITian's that they flew the only difference between you and them is they still love there country and Education given to them.They have always taken the appreciation given to them.They are special because they believe so but you are not because you don't..IIT were opened to share a Vision ..A Vision of some patriotic people who thought the children delivering with a small amount of course with there right direction of thinking will always be helpful to there nation directly or indirectly.I think that's true.And its upto us to keep it alive...In sanskrita I read one poem which meant" for your family you should leave your self-love, for your village sacrifice your own family-love and for nation you should never think of anyother thing.."....Over the ages and struggle with corruption and defeat we had again and again now the order has changed totally...Those who flew are just persons taking advantage of everything provided to them in order to get a better,safe and luxurious life...I am fighting and I'll fight until I am ...And one day I'll prove this self-love is the first love thing wrong...I am taught 8 poor kids for 14 days and My friend I came to know that we were selected more easily with actual talent lagging behind...In IIT's you were never told to stay out of touch with other world...I read everyday the news paper , everyday I counted how many soldiers died fighting to provide you secure nation who's children now are homeless as per law of our armed forces..My friend with every breeze of change there is blood and a tears involved.Blood you never saw , tears you never cared about...Whoever is indian ,They are our brothers they should never be hated not atleast by us..."If you want a change be the one"...Believe in yourself because people think you are special and you are in all ways..We've to take our nation to a better level...Join us in this War...A war against the devided society among corrupted and honests..This is what I've learned,I am telling you because I think you need this...You are my brother as an IITian and as Indian...This is what IIT's are giving you my friend..Accept it...Teach someone a lot better then you were ever taught....
Thanks
Mayank
Mayank
bangalore, India
Oct 07, 2009 07:44 PM
18
One reason why IITs are not able to deliver world-class reseach, despite honest competitive selections of students, and faculty [before start of in-breeding], is the fact that they are admn-heavy like all public-sector undertakings. academic freedom given in subjects taught, projects chosen. but, project implementation and expends by faculty, in general, are hindered by red-tape delays and bureaocratic over-drives. the number of admn staff is three or four times that of faculty, quite reducible, in these cptr-internet days!

in uk, usa, scientists are given trust, freedom, facilities, without too much admn rigmarole and redtape. VCs receive funds, assign to depts, only ask how much more reqd, if finished!. orders for expt/proj-equipment can be placed on phone, bills passed on supply, by just the signature of scientist concerned on the back of the bill, not even the HoD! they can concentrate on jobs, instead of going after regr/director fotr purchase approvals. in india, iits also, orders thro admn take months to be sent, tenders themselves become invalid before orders materialize!. burocrats want to control the faculty and lab-staff. In iitm, some major projs of mine had to be left incomplete, bec of excessive purchase-process delays. non-utilized grants are spent wastefully at the end of finance yr, on additional storage equipment, to avoid the lapse of grants.

when I was in uk, cranfield, as visit-prof, my lect-colleague there took me on a visit to sheffield. took his car, filled gas, signed on bill for univ to pay. we made a useful trip. an iitm-prof, for such a visit, even to IISc, Blore, to be paid for, will require weeks of approval processing, from the director down to clerk!.

The brits have left india as a colony with a clerk-prone mindset. that is the problem. the crooked-criminal polits, who have taken over from the brits, have only made matters worse. They also control all private educ institutions now. no chances, for nobel prizes, only ignoble brain-drains! only nris prove our basic indian potential for excellence by getting nobel prizes etc.
v.seshadri
chennai, india
Oct 07, 2009 04:25 AM
17
Sad to see that the author still could not get over it after 10 years. I graduated in 98 from KGP and most of the guys were total assholes,rude, and obnoxious while all we had done was clear an exam in elementary Maths, Physics and Chemistry. This whole propaganda about IITs need to stop. It is not even a research institute. Just a glorified undergrad school. My conclusion: A total waste of 4 years.
tejinder
st louis, United States
Oct 06, 2009 05:40 AM
16
IITs have totally failed to live up to the expectations of Nehru. IITs were supposed to be the centers of innovations and their graduates were supposed to be innovators. Nehru was a visionary the type of which we have not seen since. Rajiv showed some promise but went away very early in his life. Rajiv was responsible for the IT and Telecom revolution. Anyway if the IITs had produced the Technocrat leadership Nehru had envisioned, we would have been on equal footing with all the knowledge economies rather than the fodder for US MNCs and US research communities.

This is an age of knowledge. May be we the Indian society have also failed to spark the imagination of IIT graduates and provide them with challages. We need to do our bit because knowledge and innovation is critical for survival in this age. Every nation is trying very hard. We need the brightest of our country to stay back and help the country grow in this age of knowledge. HRD minister can help realise the vision of Nehru.
JayKay Chraborty
Kolkatta, India
Oct 05, 2009 08:46 PM
15
THOKA bhai.........
i think you are really confused stuff.
"Contrary to popular belief, the vast majority of IITians do nothing of note in their lives..."
its your perception and your opinion.... i would not have taken time to comment on this but as you are also
"Deputy Editor of Outlook" i am putting my comments . i think before writing these stuffs you should do some survey while saying "majority of IITians" and write logically giving the reference.
My batchmates from KGP are IAS, IPS , IRS and other Civil services job serving Goverment of India....One of my IPS friend was hit by bullet while leading an operation.
one of mate from KGP has been working selflessly in NGO in kolkata . he is also IIM-C alumni.
now abt friends in USA , Many of my mates are in research work which ultimately will lead for better technology for mankind. There are many stories .....
Don'nt put your frustation of your life on KGPian...
wase thoka ho kuch bhe leko chalega.....
papi singh
New Delhi, India
Oct 04, 2009 07:07 AM
14
IITIANS need to stop living in past when they might be the cream of india while entering iit after cracking jee..those days are gone when u enter in iit and complete the 2.2 of kgp.
rather one should live in present and boldly face the present scenerio and one more thing..
one need to aspire big to do big.. iit nametag is not going to ripe fruits for us... we need to put efforts for it.
Vineet
kharagpur, India
Oct 04, 2009 07:02 AM
13
Dude com'on.
kab tak kgp ko yaad karte rahoge..
the popular belief is popular because its true tht very few iitians do things tht are big...
and its also true tht ppl from other branches do a lot of better things thn us.. reason is simple.
most iitians donot have a vision and they live in the world of dreams of being an iitian and when its time for performance they settle on 6 digit salary and enjoy their married life..they donot have visions to work..
few rarely aspire big and put real efforts.. and these ew are the only which do something with their life...
Vineet
kharagpur, India
Oct 04, 2009 01:39 AM
12
Its high time, IITians get away from the highly artificial world they live in and get in touch with the real world. For starters, increasing number of girls would help in a better studying environment. I am an IITian myself and I find IITians lacking in communication, soft-skills as well as relationships too.
Increasing number of IITs would help reduce the surely help reduce the false superiority complex and the move to start courses such as humanities, law and medicine in IIT are welcome too. Fine arts and other streams should be included too.
Kapil Sibbal is doing a very good job. More people will access to merit based quality education.
Forget about the brand value reduction. How many people go into tech anyway. Its time merit gets valued than brand alone.
Chinmay
Ahmedabad, India
Oct 03, 2009 10:50 PM
11
Below is an excerpt from a chat with a friend of mine about this article -

George: thts a confused article
:P
me: yeah man
thats what i told u
George: i dont see his point
me: hardly looks professional
more like someone's spontaneous rambling
he's like iitians dont do two bits but still we ought to be proud of ourselves coz of the relationships we forge
George: u get high
and then ramble
sounds like that
me: hehe .. its as confused as sth from a personal diary of a teenager
George: hahaha
we shud tell him that
me:yeah let me find the link
man we need to register to comment
anyways .. i am bored enough to give it a try
George: dude why do iitians have to always be authorities on iitians :P
everyones an authority dude
iitians aise hai
iitians waise hai
if theres one thing pple llike to do in india..its stereotype iitians
lol
me: thats why the best candidates to bust them are iitians themselves
George: but therey not
lol
theyre playing into them
lol
me: i have read some iitians who are not that elitist
George: tht would be an intersting read
me: the society here eulogises them coz here ppl define success as a high paying job , financial security etc
that iitians deliver mostly
but anyone who has the sense to think beyond that
is critical of the tag
even our profs dont think much of us undergrads
:P
George: hmm
me: okay done with the registration
George: read ur comment
me: theres another comment below mine
read that too
George: yeah
read it
thts legit too ..to an extent
me: yeah man totally
George: dude lotsa pple are close to their batchmates
me: dude its just that u are in a hostel for 4 years
me: doesnt matter if its an iit
infact if it werent iit we would have done more stuff together prolly
:P
and may be stronger bonds
George: hahaha
me: this is total self-love
lol
George: yeah
so even if things arent going well
we're from IIT so hey..we're still better cause we're from IIT and everything is worth it
me: haha
lol
its totally overdone this time and coming from a person who is supposed to know better
deputy editor of outlook and ****
George: yeah i kno right
its like he is balancing his midlife crisis by reminicing bout iit
on as public a forum as possible
me: dude post that
me: i bet he'll flip over
and then there will be some comments like what do u know
u are not an iiitian
George: hahahaha
me: u just rue them
:P
George: yeah
u want to be ME
my life is complete caus i went to an IIT :P
me: and god knows how they came to the conclusion that JEE is the ultimate yardstick of intelligence
George: srsly dude
me: should be awarded a nobel prize in psychology at least
poor chaps have been struggling with the concept of measuring intelligence forever

me: iitians need to get over themselves
and the society too
and dude theres a line in the article
"The confidence eroded a bit over the years, and we learnt some humility when we discovered non-IITians as smart as we were, and also people who could outwit us because they were intelligent in a different way - in a sly political way-an acumen we had not developed in our isolated environment"
why the heck there cant be people who could outwit you because they were more intelligent in the exactly same way as you were but never bothered to write the jee
George: i kno right
delusions of grandeur
its sad he's not some random idiot
he's actually an ediotr
me: thats the worst part
i feel like pasting this whole chat there
George: HAHAHA
me: will save a lot of effort for me of writing a separate comment
lol that editor will be like .. "crap .. people actually read it ... i just thought it was my personal diary"
George: he thot tht he will write this article..then iitans from around the world will flock to it and sing his praises
me: some did do that though :|
Ankur
delhi, India
Oct 03, 2009 09:42 PM
10
I am sorry to say that this article is as confused as ramblings taken from the personal diary of a teenager. Is the author trying to say that though IITians do not contribute much to the society they have all the reason to be proud of themselves just because of the relationships they forge during their college. Sounds hilarious!!
Ankur
delhi, India
Oct 03, 2009 03:55 PM
9
"Never were stronger bonds forged between young people. "

Wrong. Please do not think the rest of the world is bad at making bonds. I ain't an IIT product. Been with many IITians and find,their bonds are only as good as the bonds 'common' humans make. :)
No offense meant. But that is how things are. And I felt I should bring that to your notice.

Cheerz!
DN
Durga Nandan
Thrissur, India
Oct 03, 2009 02:53 AM
8
dats the most touching article about kgp life anyone myt have read...the 4/5 years of lyf we had spent here have been beautifully encased in one single page....the life here is much more beautiful jus like a frozen snowing lake wid a couple dancing on it all encased in a glass ball...n it ll sure luk magnificent to the ppl outside dat glass ball...simple yet very different and magnificent...great work sandy sir :-)
pranav
kharagpur, India
Jun 27, 2002 12:00 AM
7
IIT KGP:98 Pass out - Maths and Computing.

Over the years, I had started believing that our old IIT values have totally eroded over the years - the philosophies/ethics for which we used to quarrel nights without numbers were all lost in a dusty sack - specially after observing most of my batch-mates...but this column is exceptional. I dont believe a better article can be written on the life and life-values of an IIT an.
Hats Off!

Regards
-Subhendu
Subhendu Mukherjee
Minneapolis, USA
Jun 27, 2002 12:00 AM
6
Sandipan must have been in IIT some time back. But, his article quite correctly reflects the situation even now. As a present student of IIT Delhi, I could feel the words, literally. I don't agree with everything Sandipan says. But, you can't really agree on everything.
IIT has been a a very special experience till now, and it is still continuing. And contrary to popular belief, my 'experience' has been largely devoid of Academics. And that's true for quite a majority here. IIT is a great place because of the people you meet here, the hostel you live in, the life you live-including friends,inter-hostel competitions,Rendezvous, politics,last-minute exam preparations,the unending chit-chat sessions in hostel rooms,so many things....
Only one sore point:The administration. The vast 'bright' majority loses interest in Academics. It can't entirely be students' fault.

PS:It is good to find an alumni in such a 'different' profession.
K D
Delhi, India
Jun 15, 2002 12:00 AM
5
very interesting
it reminded me ofmy stay in the hostel
sonia andrews
trivandrum, india
Jun 14, 2002 12:00 AM
4
Thanks for the wonderfull piece, it has helped me to gain a whole new insight into somebody very dear, somebody from IIT, Kharagpur...
Ishani
Calcutta, India
Oct 30, 2002 12:00 AM
3
Dear Editor,

I am a subscriber to Outlook for the past 4 years. I would like you to publish the following in Outlook.

A lot of heat has generated in the past week over the ordinance on conversions issue by the Tamil Nadu Government. For her part, The chief Minister of Tamil Nadu, Ms.J.Jayalalithaa needs to be lauded on bringing such an ordinance. it is important to understand the fact on whether conversions are voluntary or forced. Mot of them are forced, alluring the poor into a trap. If a person converts his religion, he can do so voluntarily. Two examples of conversions come to mind - that of B.R.Ambedkar into Buddhism and the recently, of music whiz A.R.Rahman into Islam. Conversion is perfect as long it is voluntary. But these missionaries lure the poor into a trap with stories of "the blind can see, the lame can walk" and the like and it ends up in brain-washing the same.The reactions of the two proselyting religions is to be seen. The Muslim community has reacted lukewarmly to the ordinace, which reflects their stand on the ordinance. But the Christian leaders have raised a hue and cry over it, which reflects on the "missionary zeal" with which these Christian leaders carry out their "work". If this becomes a law, it can very well help restoring the secular fabric of the nation as people will actually begin to trust each other.

Vasumathy V

Vasumathy V
Chennai, India
Oct 30, 2002 12:00 AM
2
Hi Sandipan

Isn't it wonderful to connect for the only reason that we walked the same roads and classrooms?

Everyone has their IIT Kharagpur perhaps, but somehow the feeling persists - KGP really is something else, and I think what you point out - the isolation, the tribal togetherness - makes the difference.

It was fun reliving that tribal feeling. Tarapodo ka Tempo High Hai!



Ranga Kandadai
Pune, India
Oct 30, 2002 12:00 AM
1
Congratulations, Sandipan, on a wonderfully written piece. Its like you've put my own thoughts to words. Three years out of Kharagpur and I am realizing that the "real world" is very different from our Kharagpur campus -- and this is the world I will live in for the rest of my days. Whether these days are spent in mediocrity or in fame, the experiences from Kharagpur will be with me, always.

And, yes, my yearly wing-reunions do take me back to the good ol' KGP. Each time I see any of my wing-mates, I sing to myself the famous lines by Elizabeth Akers Allen --

Backward, turn backward, O Time, in your flight
Make me a child again, just for tonight!
Vivek
College Station, USA
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY